FDO: The Ultimate Catch-22

FDO: The Ultimate Catch-22


With Keith re-shorting FDO last week, here’s some quick insight into why we are (and have been) so fundamentally negative on this name.


At this point in the cycle, it’s no surprise that the weak economy and its disproportionate impact on low and middle income consumers has been a key driver to the dollar stores and deep discounters over the past 12-18 months.  The weak macro environment makes this sub-sector of retailing the ultimate Catch-22 when it comes to success.  Essentially, as our nation’s economy faltered and less people were employed, retailers like FDO and DG benefited.  In other words, one man’s pain is another man’s pleasure.  And while morally it’s a bit conflicting to bet on the fragility of the American consumer, we know that placing bets is what the Street is all about.  So morals aside, outsized same store sales gains (relative to history) driven by sharp pricing, EBT usage (food stamps), and quite simply necessity have propelled the topline performance of FDO, DG, DLTR, and NDN beyond “normal” levels.  Along the way, gross margins and expense leverage have benefitted and EBIT margins have inched their way towards historical highs.  This all sounds like a perfect set up, but how long can this last? 


Within the context of the cash strapped consumer, Family Dollar has been a relative laggard.  Yes, the same store sales did accelerate late in 2008, resulting in historically high sales growth for three of the last five quarters.  However, the company has been unsuccessful in maximizing this trend on a consistent year over year basis.  For two quarters in a row now, same store sales have been disappointing, missing both company guidance and Street expectations.  What is more troubling is that momentum in the most recent quarter slowed on easier comparisons, and now the company faces its toughest compares (through June) in the past seven years!  Quite simply, Family Dollar’s pace of share gain has slowed and it’s only going to get tougher.  Same store sales are likely to turn flat through the first half of the year, leaving little room for expense leverage, let alone multiple expansion.  At the same time FDO (and others) are ramping up unit growth in 2010, which will not only put pressure on the P&L but increase the likelihood for cannibalization and competition.  We’re all for being opportunistic, but can the U.S retail landscape really handle an additional 1,100 units annually for the next few years?


 FDO: The Ultimate Catch-22 - FDO  DG  WMT comp chart 2yr


To be fair, maybe we’re being too harsh and should consider the other side of the story.  Let’s look at the biggest risk factors associated with a negative view on FDO and the space in general:


  • The classic Depressionista set up. The economy takes another leg down, leaving more middle and upper middle income consumers in the sweet spot for dollar store shopping.  Incremental traffic is getting harder to come by, but a new wave of potential customers seeking deep discount consumables would enable FDO, DG, and others to extend their runs. 
  • The trade off scenario. The economy improves and along with it sales of higher margin discretionary products pick up.  This affords FDO the opportunity to drive higher average transactions and also a more profitable basket.  Offsetting this pick up is the likelihood that some portion of the FDO’s middle income customer base sees economic relief as the overall macro backdrop improves.  This results in slowing traffic and sales as this consumer begins to shop elsewhere, returning to a routine that likely involves more trips to a Target or a Kroger.  In a perfect world, sales slow, margins expand, and the Street is OK with it. 
  • The growth trumps all thesis.  After 4 years of moderating new store growth, management regains confidence that there is ample opportunity to grow the FDO store base.  Although expectations are for a modest ramp to 500 new stores per year over the next 2-3 years, management decides to seize the moment and ramp up sooner.   With DG and DLTR also growing rapidly, one must really be on board with bullet #1 to get comfortable with over 1,100 new units opening across the U.S each year.  There is no other sub-sector of retailing that will see as much square footage growth over the next 3-4 years.  We just wonder if growth for the sake of growth can drive multiples at this point. 


So at the end of the day that leaves us and Keith (with his re-initiated short position) with a negative bias on FDO shares in the near to intermediate term.  We’re carefully watching for the risk factors associated with a name that it is so highly leveraged to the most economically challenged consumer in the U.S economy.  For now though, we’re comfortable that the reward for slowing sales far outweighs the risk of the Catch-22.


FDO: The Ultimate Catch-22 - FDO SIGMA



Cartoon of the Day: Acrophobia

"Most people who are making a ton of money right now are focused on growth companies seeing accelerations," Hedgeye CEO Keith McCullough wrote in today's Early Look. "That’s what happens in Quad 1."

read more

People's Bank of China Spins China’s Bad-Loan Data

PBoC Deputy Governor Yi says China's non-performing loan problem has “pretty much stabilized." "Yi is spinning. China’s bad-debt problem remains serious," write Benn Steil and Emma Smith, Council on Foreign Relations.

read more

UnderArmour: 'I Am Much More Bearish Than I Was 3 Hours Ago'

“The consumer has a short memory.” Yes, Plank actually said this," writes Hedgeye Retail analyst Brian McGough. "Last time I heard such arrogance was Ron Johnson."

read more

Buffalo Wild Wings: Complacency & Lack of Leadership (by Howard Penney)

"Buffalo Wild Wings has been plagued by complacency and a continued lack of adequate leadership," writes Hedgeye Restaurants analyst Howard Penney.

read more

Todd Jordan on Las Vegas Sands Earnings

"The quarter actually beat lowered expectations. Overall, the mass segment performed well although base mass lagging is a concern," writes Hedgeye Gaming, Lodging & Leisure analyst Todd Jordan on Las Vegas Sands.

read more

An Update on Defense Spending by Lt. Gen Emo Gardner

"Congress' FY17 omnibus appropriation will fully fund the Pentagon's original budget request plus $15B of its $30B supplemental request," writes Hedgeye Potomac Defense Policy analyst Lt. Gen Emerson "Emo" Gardner USMC Ret.

read more

Got Process? Zero Hedge Sells Fear, Not Truth

Fear sells. Always has. Look no further than Zero Hedge.

read more

REPLAY: Review of $EXAS Earnings Call (A Hedgeye Best Idea Long)

Our Healthcare Team made a monster call to be long EXAS - hear their updated thoughts.

read more

Capital Brief: 5 Things to Watch Right Now In Washington

Here's a quick look at some key issues investors should keep an eye on from Hedgeye's JT Taylor and our team of Washington Policy analysts in D.C.

read more

Premium insight

[UNLOCKED] Today's Daily Trading Ranges

“If I could only have one thing of the many things we have it would be my daily ranges." Hedgeye CEO Keith McCullough said recently.

read more

We'll Say It Again: Leave Your Politics Out of Your Portfolio

If your politics dictates your portfolio positioning, the Democrats and #NeverTrump crowd out there have had a hell of a week.

read more

Cartoon of the Day: 'Biggest Tax Cut Ever'

President Donald Trump's economic team unveiled what he called last week, "the biggest tax cut we’ve ever had.” Before you get too excited about that hang on a sec. "Trump Tax Reform ain’t gettin’ done anytime soon," Hedgeye CEO Keith McCullough wrote in today's Early Look.

read more