Chipotle ... Delusional

Takeaway: Flying Blind + Blind Faith = a great SHORT selling combination...

Editor's Note: This is a brief excerpt from a recent institutional research report written by our Restaurants team. If you would like access to our research please email


Chipotle ... Delusional - z chip


Chipotle (CMG) is on our Hedgeye Restaurants Best Ideas list as a SHORT.



Even with a disastrous sales update after the close, we still feel like we’re fighting an uphill battle on the CMG short call, but make no mistake, our conviction level is very high!  The CMG management team is flying blind and has no practical experience in recovering from one of the greatest foodborne illness disasters ever experienced by a restaurant company.  That opinion and the blind faith the street has put in this management team makes for a great SHORT selling combination.   



In part, our conviction level remains high because the company was experiencing growth related issues in 3Q15, prior to the company’s 4Q15 sales related issues.  Bottom line, CMG should have slowed unit growth following the 3Q15 earnings and not accelerated it! The three biggest problems the company faced then and still face today are:

  1. Limited supply of quality real estate
  2. Significantly higher lease rates for the sites they do open
  3. Lower average unit volumes


Taken together, all three suggest significantly lower returns and an increased likelihood that the company will not get the units open on time, or will compromise the quality of the openings to meet Wall Street expectations.


The other key to the SHORT case...


***Please email if you are interested in our institutional research.

Starts | Hurdling Pygmies

Takeaway: February Housing Starts bounced off easy sequential and Y/Y comps, but softening builder confidence (HMI 58) bodes poorly.

Our Hedgeye Housing Compendium table (below) aspires to present the state of the housing market in a visually-friendly format that takes about 30 seconds to consume.



Starts | Hurdling Pygmies - Compendium 031616

Today’s Focus:  February Housing Starts & Permits

We knew this morning’s Starts data for February was going to be solid; Base effects were exceedingly easy given severe weather last year and seasonals were equally supportive as each of the last two years saw weather depressed Februaries give way to rebound strength in April/May (see 1st chart below).  Next month’s March data should benefit from a similar dynamic.   


So, we successfully hurdled the easy comp, now what? 


The answer carries some duration sensitivity:


  • Total Starts | Flat-lining:  New construction activity has shown a clear but crawling trend higher since 2010 and the longer-term mean reversion upside to average historical levels of activity remains an opportunity. Inclusive of the sequential improvement in February, however, Total Starts have been flat to down for the last 10-months (see 2nd chart below) and permits, while stable-to-modestly better, aren’t signaling a meaningful acceleration over the nearer-term. 
  • SF vs MF | Mix Shift:  Mix has shifted  over the last year as multi-family activity has moderated back towards 2014 levels while SF construction has shown offsetting improvement.  Whether funding stress and a higher cost of capital for CRE weighs on multi-family construction remains to be seen.  Domestic age and racial demographics will remain supportive of rental demand for the foreseeable future but rental affordability is already stretched and Shelter inflation in this morning’s CPI report made another higher high at +3.28% YoY.  A similar pace of rental price inflation could persist further but rental cost burdens are already at historic highs and rent price growth can only run at a steep premium to income growth for so long. 
  • Starts vs Sales | A Tale of Two Slopes:  Builder Confidence sits at a 9-month low and the slope of sales in the New Home Market is negative (3rd chart below).  These measures stand in notable contrast to the flat trend in total starts and positive slope in SF construction over the TTM.


On balance, the data mosaic across housing continues to support our negative outlook.   As the data stands, we would not view slowing HPI, decelerating volume growth in the existing market, flatlined Starts activity and negative 2nd derivative trends in New Home Sales and Builder Confidence as a particularly bullish fundamental factor constellation, especially heading into the seasonally tough 2Q/3Q equity performance periods (see last 2 charts below).




Starts | Hurdling Pygmies - Starts Total and SF Seasonality


Starts | Hurdling Pygmies - Starts Total


Starts | Hurdling Pygmies - Sales vs Starts TTM


Starts | Hurdling Pygmies - Starts   Permits MF TTM


Starts | Hurdling Pygmies - Starts   Permits SF TTM


Starts | Hurdling Pygmies - Starts LT


Starts | Hurdling Pygmies - Starts SF 


Starts | Hurdling Pygmies - seasonality table


Starts | Hurdling Pygmies - seasonality chart




About Housing Starts & Permits:

The US Census Bureau records the number of new housing units that have obtained permits for construction and those that have begun construction. This data includes new buildings intended primarily as residential units. The US Census Bureau defines a start as, “Start of construction occurs when excavation begins for the footings or foundation of a building.” 




Joshua Steiner, CFA


Christian B. Drake


WSM | 50% of Growth Slowing?

Takeaway: We don’t think WSM is a short. But with 50% of growth appearing to slow materially, we wouldn’t touch WSM ahead of the print on either side.

Despite a 35% draw down from peak-to-tough, a less than impressive performance in the ‘junk rebound rally’ we’re seen over the past six weeks, AND a generally positive predisposition toward the name longer-term, we simply can’t get excited about WSM over the near-term.


Yes, there are a few positive factors – let’s get those out of the way.


1) The RH blowup earlier this quarter was much less about macro and more about execution hiccups/burps/projectile vomiting associated with launching new concepts. The promotional fears are real, but we’d argue that’s what drove the negative bifurcation in performance between the home furnishings names and the broader retail index starting in mid-November.


2) Numbers printed out of LZB, PIR, KIRK, and ETH have looked better than feared – pretty much across the board. Granted, this is not the most appropriate sample (though RH is not either), but the average PM probably throws them all in the same bucket – for better or worse. 


3) WSM is lapping its own set of executional headwinds caused by the West Coast port delays in 1H15 which cost the company $30-$40mm on the top line and 50bps+ of margin in each of the first two quarters of 2015. Normalized product flow should allow the company to recapture a large portion of that, at least on the margin side. We’d really argue that its own complex operational structure (between e-commerce and B&M) simply could not handle the stress of an event like a Port Strike (why are there fewer than five companies in all of retail that repeatedly talked about this, despite the fact that everyone sources from the same place?). Nonetheless, an easy comp is an easy comp.


While all that matters, the unfortunate reality is that the growth story and stock drivers for WSM are almost entirely hinged on the West Elm concept. That might sound strange given the fact that the brand is only 17% of sales but a) it’s the only concept in the portfolio of brands actually growing square footage, and b) West Elm has accounted for ~50% of incremental growth for the better part of two years, which is evidenced by the first chart below.  We think that’s potentially at risk.


We triangulate several sources for every company each quarter to gauge the online sales curve vs a year ago. These sources have tracked West Elm well in the past. They’re the same sources that are suggesting to us that 50% of growth might have meaningfully decelerated, as outlined in the second chart below. The quarter might still be fine, as the Street is looking for just 4% EPS growth. But in 1Q expectations accelerate to 14%, which might lead WSM to an underwhelming guide.  Does the Street know this with short interest at a 5-year high and 10.5% of the float? Probably. But we’re not suggesting that this is a great short here. We’re simply saying that despite our temptations, our process tells us that this is absolutely not a buy before the event.


WSM | 50% of Growth Slowing? - 3 16 2016 Chart1 WSM growth

WSM | 50% of Growth Slowing? - 3 16 2016 Chart2

Attention Students...

Get The Macro Show and the Early Look now for only $29.95/month – a savings of 57% – with the Hedgeye Student Discount! In addition to those daily macro insights, you'll receive exclusive content tailor-made to augment what you learn in the classroom. Must be a current college or university student to qualify.

Hedgeye TV | Restaurants & Consumer Staples LIVE + Interactive Wednesday at 2:15PM ET

Catch us LIVE in the studio Wednesday at 2:15PM ET.


We will discuss key issues affecting investors including industry trends, recent developments and provide an overview of our best ideas, including Chipotle Mexican Grill (CMG)McDonalds (MCD)Hain Celestial Group (HAIN)Darden Restaurants (DRI) and Snyder's-Lance (LNCE).


***Have a question? Enter it in the chat box under the video player and we will answer them live!



Hedgeye TV | Restaurants & Consumer Staples LIVE + Interactive Wednesday at 2:15PM ET - rest consumerstaples

Hedgeye TV | Restaurants & Consumer Staples LIVE + Interactive Wednesday at 2:15PM ET

Catch us LIVE in the studio Wednesday at 2:15PM ET.


We will discuss key issues affecting investors including industry trends, recent developments and provide an overview of our best ideas, including Chipotle Mexican Grill (CMG)McDonalds (MCD)Hain Celestial Group (HAIN)Darden Restaurants (DRI) and Snyder's-Lance (LNCE).


***Have a question? Enter it in the chat box under the video player and we will answer them live!


CLICK HERE to watch live.

Hedgeye TV | Restaurants & Consumer Staples LIVE + Interactive Wednesday at 2:15PM ET - rest consumerstaples

What To Watch Ahead Of Hawkish Fed Day

Takeaway: What if the dollar falls post-Fed Day? What should you buy on US economic #GrowthSlowing?

What To Watch Ahead Of Hawkish Fed Day - rate hike cartoon 11.17.2015


Remember what happened last time the Fed tightened into a slow-down (DEC)?


"The market expects a relatively hawkish Fed today," writes Hedgeye CEO Keith McCullough in a note sent to subscribers this morning:


"Not surprisingly, USD is up (this wk) into the “relatively hawkish” #LateCycle Employment Fed statement – but how much USD (and rates) upside is there? Not much for now, as both the Japanese and European #BeliefSystem of FX devaluation continues to break-down, pressuring USD inasmuch as slowing housing and consumption data does."



So get ready ahead of a hawkish Fed Day:


"Right there with the Financials (XLF -6.0% YTD) as Best Ideas Shorts in 2016 YTD is the Russell 2000 (down -1.6% yesterday to -6.1% YTD) as both are much purer plays on the short side of the US economy slowing than the global one. I know that doesn’t fit the permabull narrative. But it does fit yesterday’s US Retail Sales and Housing (NAHB) data! #slowing."



Which gets us back to what happened after the December rate hike. Well, stocks tumbled and bond yields fell.



get free cartoon of the day!

Start receiving Hedgeye's Cartoon of the Day, an exclusive and humourous take on the market and the economy, delivered every morning to your inbox

By joining our email marketing list you agree to receive marketing emails from Hedgeye. You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in one of the emails.