Guest Contributor: China’s Exorbitant Detriment Is Costing It Dearly

by Benn Steil and Emma Smith


Guest Contributor: China’s Exorbitant Detriment Is Costing It Dearly - benn stiel


The so-called Exorbitant Privilege of the United States, the power to conjure the world’s primary reserve currency, is reflected in the unique combination of being deeply in debt to the rest of the world (that is, having a massive negative net international investment position, or NIIP) while earning far more income abroad than it pays out in interest (that is, having massive positive annual net investment income, or NII). 


The U.S. NIIP averaged negative $7.5 trillion over FY15/16, while its NII was positive $167 billion, as shown in the top left of the graphic above. Basically, foreigners are willing to accept a trivial return to hold dollar-denominated assets.


Far less well known is the mirror-image of the Exorbitant Privilege, or what we might call the Exorbitant Detriment. It is, not surprisingly, borne by China. It is, to some extent, the price the country bears as the world’s largest holder of dollar-denominated central bank reserves. Reserves account for half of China’s foreign assets, of which around 40 percent are invested in low-yielding U.S. Treasury securities.


But it also reflects the fact that China is lending to the rest of the world at paltry rates. Chinese government institutions lend to Chinese, as well as foreign, firms operating abroad far more cheaply than alternative lenders. This reflects the Chinese government’s efforts both to subsidize its companies and to strengthen economic ties with resource-rich countries in, for example, Africa and Latin America. China’s Exorbitant Detriment is reflected in an NIIP of $1.6 trillion and NII of negative $80 billion in FY15/16.


Can China continue supporting its Exorbitant Detriment indefinitely? Not if it wants to prioritize a halt to reserve sales, which have been necessitated by capital outflows. Negative investment income reduces the current account surplus, and therefore the amount of capital that can leave the country before the central bank has to match outflows with reserve sales.


If China’s investment income balance had been zero over FY15/16 it would, all else being equal, have been able to absorb an additional $80 billion of capital outflows before having to sell reserves. This is equivalent to 17 percent of the actual decline in reserves over this period. China’s reserves fell to $3 trillion in December and, as we pointed out in an earlier post, could actually fall to what the IMF reserve-analysis rubric would deem dangerously low levels by summer if outflows continue at the pace seen over the last three months. 


China can slow this decline by demanding higher returns on its lending abroad, but this will require sacrificing its efforts to subsidize its companies as well as those aimed at putting dollars to the service of geostrategic objectives.



This is a Hedgeye Guest Contributor piece written by Benn Steil and Emma Smith and reposted from the Council on Foreign Relations’ Geo-Graphics blog. Mr Steil is director of international economics at the Council on Foreign Relations and author of The Battle of Bretton Woods. It does not necessarily reflect the opinion of Hedgeye.

Cartoon of the Day: The Education of A Permabear

Stock market permabears have been getting shellacked. In the past three months, the S&P 500 is up +6% and Russell 2000 is up +10.6%. What they haven't figured out yet is that U.S. economic growth is accelerating.

read more

ICYMI: Why We’re Bullish on the S&P 500

Are you bullish on U.S. equities? You should be. In addition to the U.S. economy supporting higher equity markets, a number of market signals confirm the bullish setup for stocks.

read more

Premium insight

Fox News And Media Leaks May Boost AT&T-Time Warner Deal

More media reports that the President-elect may look for reasons to fight the T-TWX deal. Ironically, the reports boost the deal's prospects.

read more

Premium insight

3 Reasons Why You Should Sell GrubHub | $GRUB

Wall Street loves GrubHub. But should it? Check-out the three reasons why we think GrubHub is a short.

read more

Guest Contributor: 3 Tips for Stressed-Out Traders To Bolster Financial Success (Part 1)

Three tips to control psychological well-being and bolster financial success.

read more

Cha-Ching! U.S. Wage Growth Hits Post-Recession High

After years of stagnation, worried Rust Belt Trump voters are finally getting the bump up in their pay stubs for which they've long yearned. More is coming. Here's why.

read more

Cartoon of the Day: Japan's Hungry Bulls

Simple ... Yen ↓ = Nikkei ↑ ... In the past three months, the Yen has weakened -10% against the U.S. Dollar. The Nikkei is up 15% over that same period.

read more

ICYMI: A Simple Way to Profit on Oil’s Bullish Trend

“I’m not just bullish on oil because oil is going up. On the up moves in oil, we’ve seen rising volume and breaking down volatility.”

read more

5 Things To Watch Right Now In Washington

It's going to be an interesting four years to say the least. Here's a quick look at four key issues investors should keep an eye on as Trump prepares to move into the White House.

read more

Poll of the Day: Which Country Poses the Biggest Risk to Global Market Stability?

What do you think? Cast your vote. Let us know.

read more