prev

CMG: SIMPLY INCREDIBLE

CMG continues to be one of our core longs.

 

CMG: SIMPLY INCREDIBLE - 333

 

Comps: CMG delivered +17.3% comp growth in the quarter, beating estimates of +10.2%, led by traffic and, to a lesser extent, a +5% increase in average check (+2.5% price; +2.5% benefit from catering/side orders).  Management upped its FY14 comp guidance once again, from high-single digit growth to mid-teens growth.  Revenues of $1,050 billion (+29% YoY growth) beat consensus estimates by 6.10%.

 

Margins: Despite an accelerating topline trend, cost of sales inflation (beef, avocado, cheese) squeezed profits in the quarter – albeit to a much lesser extent than expected.  Management was able to leverage other lines, including labor and other restaurant expenses, in order to offset some of this pressure.  All told, Chipotle absolutely blew away expectations and the margin structure of the company moving forward looks quite rosy, particularly with a full price impact hitting in 2H14.

 

CMG: SIMPLY INCREDIBLE - 111

 

Earnings: Adjusted EPS of $3.50 (+24% YoY growth) beat expectations of $3.09 by 13.34%.

 

Brief Analysis: As the title says, this was simply an incredible quarter.  Coming into the print, we were slightly cautious regarding food cost inflation and the one-month effect of a price increase.  We didn’t know CMG was going to deliver +17.3% comp growth, but neither did anyone else.  Declining margins are no longer a concern, because this will end next quarter.

 

Chipotle has rolled out a 6.25-6.50% price increase system-wide, which should, by our calculation more than offset any food cost inflation.  In fact, management indicated this price increase could lead to 30%+ restaurant level margins in a best case scenario.  This hinges on several assumptions: 1) consumers continue to be receptive to price increases 2) food costs don’t increase from here and 3) consumers don’t trade down any more than they already have.  Regardless, if Chipotle can run their restaurants anywhere close to 30% margins, we’ll consider it a major feat.  We’ve always preached that Chipotle has pricing power, but finally confirmed it with today’s release of our Hedgeye Consumer Survey.  What struck us most about the results is that younger consumers, Chipotle’s core target market, are least resistant to price increases.

 

Chipotle’s unique marketing message and ability to connect with consumers isn’t the only thing driving traffic.  They also continually deliver faster throughput, increasing peak hour transactions at lunch and dinner by eight customers a piece.  Catering comprised 1.6% of sales in the quarter and reached 2% of sales in established markets.  We continue to believe this can be a meaningful driver to sales and average check over the longer-term.

 

On Friday, we also reiterated our view that Street estimates for 2H14 were too low.  With that being said, and considering management’s new SSS guidance, we expect estimates to be revised up drastically over the next several weeks. 

 

What We Liked:

  • +17.3% same-store sales growth; +11.5% two-year average
  • Management upped its FY14 comp guidance once again, from high-single digit growth to mid-teens growth
  • Revenues of $1,050 billion (+29% YoY growth) beat consensus estimates by 6.10%
  • Adjusted EPS of $3.50 (+24% YoY growth) beat expectations of $3.09 by 13.34%
  • Performance speaks to the strength of leadership teams and operating crews
  • Unparalleled food culture
  • Have begun sourcing grass fed beef from Australia in order to uphold integrity
  • Marketing efforts are really resonating; establishing emotional connections with consumers
  • Throughput continues to improve; this quarter by 8 transactions at peak hour lunch and 8 transactions at peak hour dinner
  • AUVs for restaurants in the comparable base have surpassed $2.3 million for the first time
  • Catering hit 2% of sales in established markets
  • Expect opening sales volumes in the $1.7-1.8 million range; up from prior $1.6-1.7 million
  • Underlying economic earnings growth is stronger than implied
  • Repurchased over $37 million of stock in the quarter
  • Have $140 million remaining on current share buyback program
  • Saw frequency improve in the teen market across all different economic backgrounds
  • Considering building out smaller box units with much less seating (2/3 of customers takeout)

 

What We Didn’t Like:

  • Expect steak inflation to be considerable for the foreseeable future
  • Have seen some customers trade down from steak to chicken

 

CMG: SIMPLY INCREDIBLE - 222

 

Call with questions.

 

Howard Penney

Managing Director

 

Fred Masotta

Analyst


RCL: MOMO FROM EUROPE/QUANTUM

Q2 and Q3 look like beats although we’re not sure management will raise guidance when they report company earnings on Thursday

 

 

CALL TO ACTION

RCL will report Q2 earnings this Thursday morning.  We expect a Q2 beat and while Q3 guidance could match consensus estimates, our proprietary pricing survey is suggesting another beat in Q3.  Thus, we remain above the Street for 2014 as a much stronger Europe offsets a still struggling Caribbean market.

 

ESTIMATES

We expect Q2 net yields (constant-currency) and EPS to be 2.8% and $0.54, respectively, above the consensus EPS estimate of $0.52.  Given what we’ve seen out of Europe on pricing and bookings, we expect Q3 yield guidance of +4-5%, which should be enough to placate the bears.  For Q3, we’re forecasting 4.9% net yield growth and $2.19 in EPS versus the Street EPS estimate of $2.11. 

 

EUROPE

We usually prefer to focus on sequential pricing trends as YoY pricing indicators are highly volatile and weak in their predicative power in signaling price pivots.  However, we feel it is worthwhile to highlight the rapid ascent RCL has seen in European YoY pricing as this year has progressed.

 

As seen in the chart from our mid-July pricing survey below, we believe European pricing (as weighted by brand) have averaged 15% YoY growth for Q2 sailings and averaged 10% YoY growth for Q3 sailings.  Q4 pricing is trending close to double digits YoY as well.  Given the strength in bookings, particularly for the RC brand, European yields could be +20% for Q2 and +15% for Q3.  Europe will play a prominent role in Q3 as it accounts for 44% of all RCL sailings, compared with 22% in Q2.  

 

RCL:  MOMO FROM EUROPE/QUANTUM  - rcl1

 

QUANTUM OF THE SEAS

This ‘transformational’ ship is getting quite a lot of positive buzz.  In fact, it’s one of the few bright spots in the overcrowded, fiercely competitive Caribbean market.  Agents continue to rave about Quantum, which has held pricing for its winter itineraries since we started tracking in February.  We believe Quantum will easily take over the NJ/NY market for Winter 2014/Spring 2015 Caribbean sailings, at the expense of Norwegian Gem and Breakaway

 

2015

As we look out to 2015, Quantum’s sister Anthem of the Seas is seeing increased demand for its summer 2015 sailings out of Southhampton.  RCL will need this surge as the company deals with some of the toughest comps and higher capacity in Europe.  China, while an exciting opportunity, will certainly be a wild card in the 2H of 2015.

 

CONCLUSION

We are encouraged by the sticky pricing driven partially by easy comps in Europe for the RCL brands.  Given the persistently weak pricing in the overcrowded Caribbean market, to which RCL is not immune, we do not believe RCL will raise its previously disclosed FY 2014 net yield guidance of 2-3%. However, RCL will receive a big lift in Q4 Caribbean when Quantum of the Seas hits the market in November 2014.  As we’ve seen multiple times, investors are giddy whenever a media-happy new ship is about to be deployed.


DFRG: THOUGHTS INTO THE PRINT

DFRG: THOUGHTS INTO THE PRINT - DFRG13

 

DFRG reports on Tuesday, July 22nd BMO.

 

Takeaway: DFRG remains on the Hedgeye Best Ideas list as a short.  We expect weak casual dining trends and cost of sales inflation (beef, shrimp, milk, cheese) to pressure margins in the Q.  While Del Frisco's may have pricing power at the Double Eagle concept, we doubt they have any at the other two concepts.  That said, same-store sales estimates at Grille (+2.9%) and Sullivan's (-0.1%) continue to look aggressive.

 

Investment Thesis

The company currently screens as one of the most expensive stocks on both a Price-to-Sales and EV-to-EBITDA basis in the casual dining industry.  We believe there are a number of red flags that the Street is unwilling to acknowledge right now, including decelerating same-store sales and traffic trends, declining margins, declining returns, increasing cost pressures, expensive operating leases, peak valuation, positive sentiment and high expectations.  We're confident the stock is dislocated from its intrinsic value as our sum-of-the-parts analysis suggests notable downside.  You can review our full thesis here.

 

Earnings Expectations

For 2Q14, the Street expects revenues of $69.10 million (+14% YoY), adjusted EPS of $21.00 (+4% YoY), and system-wide same-store sales of +2.3% (led by +3.6% growth at Del Frisco's Double Eagle).  We see downside to earnings driven by disappointing comps at Grille and Sullivan's as well as margin pressure due to significant food inflation.

 

Same-Store Sales Trends

Two-year same-store sales trends are plain ugly, but the Street is baking in a recovery in 2Q14.  We're slightly less optimistic.  Grille is still defining its target market and Sullivan's hasn't yet proven its capable of a turnaround.  We believe any potential upside will be driven by the Double Eagle concept, in which case management would need to be able to take ample pricing in the Q.  Certainly a risky proposition given the discounting trends we're seeing across the industry.

 

DFRG: THOUGHTS INTO THE PRINT - 22

DFRG: THOUGHTS INTO THE PRINT - dfrg3

DFRG: THOUGHTS INTO THE PRINT - dfrg4

DFRG: THOUGHTS INTO THE PRINT - dfrg5

DFRG: THOUGHTS INTO THE PRINT - dfrg12

 

Margins

The Street expects slight restaurant level and operating margin deterioration in the quarter, mostly due to food cost pressures.  The real disconnect, however, comes in back half of the year with the Street assuming restaurant level margin expansion in 3Q14 and operating margin expansion in 4Q14.  We continue to expect restaurant level and operating margin deleverage as Grille (lower margin concept) becomes a larger percentage of the portfolio.  Recall that DFRG plans to build 5 new Grille's this year and only 1 new Del Frisco's.

 

DFRG: THOUGHTS INTO THE PRINT - dfrg6

DFRG: THOUGHTS INTO THE PRINT - dfrg7

DFRG: THOUGHTS INTO THE PRINT - dfrg8

 

Valuation

DFRG is currently trading at 24.96x P/E and 11.58x EV/EBITDA on a NTM basis.  This is well ahead of its casual dining peers which, on average, trade at 17.1x P/E and 9.4x EV/EBITDA on a NTM basis.

 

DFRG: THOUGHTS INTO THE PRINT - dfrg9

DFRG: THOUGHTS INTO THE PRINT - dfrg10

 

Sentiment

77.8% of analysts rate DFRG a buy, 11.1% a hold and 11.1% a sell.  Furthermore, short interest comprises 6.59% of the float.

 

DFRG: THOUGHTS INTO THE PRINT - dfrg11

 

Risks

Immediate-term risks to the bear case include strong same-store sales trends across the board and management's ability to take ample pricing to protect margins.  Longer-term risks to the bear case include continued strength in the high-end dining category, system-wide same-store sales acceleration, a quicker than expected turnaround at Sullivan's and Grille's ability to prove itself as a legitimate growth concept in 2014. 

 

Howard Penney

Managing Director

 

Fred Masotta

Analyst


get free cartoon of the day!

Start receiving Hedgeye's Cartoon of the Day, an exclusive and humourous take on the market and the economy, delivered every morning to your inbox

By joining our email marketing list you agree to receive marketing emails from Hedgeye. You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in one of the emails.

HEDGEYE CONSUMER SURVEY: DOES CMG HAVE PRICING FLEXIBILITY?

CMG remains one of our core longs in the restaurant space.

 

With CMG getting set to release EPS after the close, one of the topics that will be top of mind is pricing and the consumer's reaction to the recent menu price increase.  We recently surveyed 500 consumers to gauge their response to Chipotle's recent menu price increase.

 

Summary: We believe CMG has the flexibility to raise prices, but as with any consumer company it is limited.  The results of our survey suggest that most consumers are resistant to the price increase, but the details under the hood suggest that CMG's core consumer is much more open to it.

 

THE HEDGEYE SURVEY

Question: Chipotle Mexican Grill is raising prices. Why will you pay more for its food?

 

Respondents were given four answers to choose from:

  1. I will not pay more
  2. Natural, high quality ingredients
  3. The speedy, customized service style
  4. Both

 

Not surprisingly, 51.4% of consumers said they would not pay more for Chipotle's food.

 

HEDGEYE CONSUMER SURVEY: DOES CMG HAVE PRICING FLEXIBILITY? - 1

 

What is interesting, however, is that 65.7% of consumers age 65+ made up the largest portion of those resistant to higher prices.  Importantly, Chipotle's key cohorts (Millenials and Gen Y) are much more forgiving about the price increase.  Additionally, the younger cohorts valued high quality ingredients more than the older cohorts.

 

HEDGEYE CONSUMER SURVEY: DOES CMG HAVE PRICING FLEXIBILITY? - 2

 

Lastly, it appears suburban consumers are far more resistant to price increases than urban consumers.

 

HEDGEYE CONSUMER SURVEY: DOES CMG HAVE PRICING FLEXIBILITY? - 3

 

If you would like more details about our Chipotle pricing survey, please give us a call.

 

Howard Penney

Managing Director

 

Fred Masotta

Analyst


Cartoon of the Day: Double Bubbles

Cartoon of the Day: Double Bubbles - Bubble chart cartoon 07.21.2014

 Social media and biotech stocks are firmly in bubble territory.

SUBSCRIBE TO CARTOON OF THE DAY.

 


VIDEO: McCullough: 'Bull Market Narrative Is Getting Ridiculous'

Hedgeye Risk Management CEO Keith McCullough and JonesTrading chief market strategist Michael O’Rourke discuss geopolitical risk and whether the bull market in stocks is getting long in the tooth on Fox Business' "Opening Bell." According to McCullough, "the real bull market is in bonds, gold, and anything slow-growth, yield-chasing that reflects a slower economy."


real-time alerts

real edge in real-time

This indispensable trading tool is based on a risk management signaling process Hedgeye CEO Keith McCullough developed during his years as a hedge fund manager and continues to refine. Nearly every trading day, you’ll receive Keith’s latest signals - buy, sell, short or cover.

next