Takeaway: It’s never stayed lower than that. And never is a long time.
A mediocre jobs report this morning indicated a 217,000 gain in employment in May, greater than the 215,000 that economists expected. Unemployment and the labor force participation rate remained unchanged at 6.3% and 62.8%, respectively.
We received mixed results this morning from BLS pertaining to restaurant industry employment, but we do have a few notable callouts. The 20-24 YOA cohort had its second best month of employment growth since June 2012, which is a bullish data point for quick-service and fast casual operators. The 45-54 YOA cohort continued its employment slump, as May marked the 19th consecutive month of employment deterioration. This continues to be, in our view, a material headwind to casual dining restaurants and, in part, leads us to believe the industry is in secular decline. However, the 55-64 YOA cohort had its second best month of employment growth since August 2013 and is, all told, a bullish data point for the casual dining industry.
In aggregate, the report was fairly mixed for the restaurant industry with perhaps the most telling data point coming in the form of strong employment growth in the 20-24 YOA cohort. We continue to favor select quick-service and fast casual operators, including YUM, CMG, WEN, JACK, PLKI and KKD. BOBE, which is one of our top long ideas, is a special situation play in the casual dining space and we are a strong advocate for change within the company, particularly a separation of the foods and restaurant businesses.
May employment growth data:
- 20-24 YOA +3.79% YoY; +148.7 bps sequentially
- 25-34 YOA +1.34% YoY; -46.1 bps sequentially
- 35-44 YOA +0.48% YoY; -38.3 bps sequentially
- 45-54 YOA -0.24% YoY; -3.1 bps sequentially
- 55-64 YOA +2.72% YoY; +73.3 bps sequentially
Employment growth across full-service restaurants, limited-service restaurants, and leisure & hospitality continues to grow at a fairly healthy clip despite a steady deceleration in two of the categories. We’d note that employment in limited-service restaurants remains the most robust and caution that growth across all three segments remains well below June 2013 levels.
In the chart below, we look at the correlation between TTM Leisure & Hospitality Employment Growth and TTM Knapp Comps. As we’ve pointed out before, Knapp same-store sales have historically tracked well with employment growth in the leisure & hospitality industry, however, this positive correlation began to break down in mid-2012. This trend continues, supporting our case that the casual dining industry is in secular decline. In this type of environment, we continue to believe that only the most nimble and innovative players will thrive.
SUMMARY: I’ve been dealing with and strategically parenting around my 18-month olds discovery of and increasing proclivity for the word “No” over the last month, so we’ll go with that as the theme for May Employment as it sufficiently characterizes this mornings release:
No change in Unemployment rate, No change in the U6-U3 spread, No change in the Labor Force Participation Rate, No acceleration in the pace of job growth, No acceleration in earnings growth, No good news for housing, No #EscapeVelocity in the labor market…and probably no change in the present policy course out of the fed.
No change in our intermediate-term outlook for growth either as we continue to think slow-growth exposure outperforms alongside rising inflation, a constrained consumer, and consensus expectations that require 4%+ GDP growth over the balance of 2014 to hit full year growth estimates. Reported Growth will obviously accelerate sequentially in 2Q14 but the TREND, at least through 3Q14, is one of deceleration.
A summary highlight of the numbers/data below:
A NEW HIGH: We eclipsed the January 2008 peak in Private employment last month and finally eclipsed the prior, Jan 2008, peak in total NFP employment by +98K with the net gain of +217K in May. The private sector’s share of total employment has increased 40bps to 84.2% compared to 83.8% prior to the recession.
State & Local Government Employment increased for a 9th consecutive month in May while the rate of job loss at the Federal level improved 60bps sequentially to -2.3% YoY. Aggregate government salary and wage growth has finally begun to contribute positively to aggregate disposable income growth.
Labor Force Participation: The participation rate was static at 62.8% MoM in May. The shift in participation by age since the start of the recession is not new, nor particularly surprising, but notably, the divergence from pre-recession levels has continued to increase moderately, not mean revert.
#HousingSlowing: Employment growth in the 25-34 year old buck decelerated for a third straight month in May. With 1st-time home buyers representing ~30% of the market and a key first rung in housing’s ladder, weak wage growth and decelerating employment trends in this key age demographic do not augur strength for forward housing demand/HPI
Earnings Growth: Average hourly earnings in the Private sector grew 2.1% YoY, up from +2.0% in April but a continuation of the stagnant 2.0% +/- 20bps that has prevailed over the last two years. Average hourly earnings for Production and Nonsupervisory employees was better, growing +2.4% YoY with the slope on the trend line still positive. (See our prior note for Labor's Bad Bank for a more detailed discussion of labor dynamics).
With earnings growth static and the spread between spending and earnings growth having re-expanded the last couple quarters, we continue to think the upside to consumption growth remains very much constrained in the immediate/intermediate term (see #Gravity: April Consumer Spending for further detail).
THE TICKING CLOCK: At 60 months as of May, the current expansion has now surpassed the mean duration of expansions (59 months) over the last century. We continue to think this reality weighs into the feds policy calculus – they need to get out of QE if only to give themselves the opportunity to (credibly) get back in if need be.
Unemployment Rate: The unemployment rate held at 6.3% in May while the U-6 rate (Unemployed + Marginally Attached + Part-time for Economic Reasons) dropped -10bps to 12.2%. Policy makers look at the spread between the two as a broad measure of labor market slack.
While the percent of LT unemployed and U-6 rate continue their steady, albeit painfully slow, march lower, the U6-U3 spread remained at 5.9% in May - well above longer-term averages which sit closer to ~3.5%
80o and Sunny on tap for the Northeast. Enjoy the weekend.
Christian B. Drake
Takeaway: Stay with what’s worked in 2014.
POSITION: 7 LONGS, 10 SHORTS
Having sent out the cover signal on the Russell lower (we have 9 consecutive wins on the short/cover signal in the Russell 2000), I was just waiting and watching for the re-short signal – and here it is.
If today’s jobs report was anything other than what it is (a lagging economic indicator), maybe I’d care about it. What I really care about is that as inflation (cost of living) continues to accelerate in the US, both the consumer and housing continue to slow.
Today you want to be doing precisely what you should have been doing 5 months ago, focusing your sales, under-weights, etc. on US domestic consumer/growth. Being long slow-growth #YieldChasing (Bonds and any stock that looks like a bond!) continues to be where the real outperformance is at.
Across our core risk management durations, here are the lines that matter to me most:
- Immediate-term TRADE resistance = 1163
- Intermediate-term TREND resistance = 1169
- Long-term TAIL risk support = 1091
In other words, the Russell 2000 continues to signal a series of lower-highs from its all-time bubble high (March 2014) and the fundamentals for US growth today are worse than they were on January 1st, 2014. Stay with what’s worked.
Keith R. McCullough
Chief Executive Officer
the macro show
what smart investors watch to win
Hosted by Hedgeye CEO Keith McCullough at 9:00am ET, this special online broadcast offers smart investors and traders of all stripes the sharpest insights and clearest market analysis available on Wall Street.