prev

YUM: THE WORST IS OVER

This note was originally published July 11, 2013 at 14:51 in Restaurants

Conclusion


Despite the significant volatility the company has faced since December 2012, YUM’s long-term growth story remains intact.  Yesterday’s earnings release suggests that the fallout from the chicken supply scandal and Avian flu issues are abating. 

 

Though we will wait for further confirmation on the near-term duration, we remain confident that the long-term upside for YUM shares represents an attractive opportunity for investors willing to look past the near-term issues.  The talk of the earnings call today quickly transitioned away from the poor results in China and toward the timing of the expected recovery in sales and margins. 

 

YUM: THE WORST IS OVER - yum

 

2Q13 Recap


The stock traded sideways as expected.  YUM reported 2Q13 EPS of $0.56 (-16% YoY) vs. Street consensus of $0.54.  During the second quarter, YUM demonstrated impressive COGS and labor controls.  The company maintained its guidance for the balance of 2013, including a 4Q turnaround in China same-store sales trends and a mid-single digit decline in 2013 EPS.  Importantly, trends in China continue to improve with June same-store sales down only 10% after coming in down 20% in May.

 

Other 2Q Highlights

  • The effective tax rate, prior to one-time items, decreased from 23.9% to 22.1%. This decrease positively impacted EPS results by 2%.
  • Same-store sales grew 1% at YRI and 1% in the U.S.
  • Both YRI and the U.S. had 80bps of restaurant margin expansion.
  • Operating profit declined 63% in China, while it increased 12% and 4% in the YRI and U.S. divisions, respectively.
  • China restaurant level margins fell 500bps in the quarter to 10.6%. 
  • Total international development included 315 new restaurants, with 76% of this development occurring in emerging markets.

 

China


The largest short-term risk to the YUM story comes from the built in expectations that China will turn the corner in 4Q13.  China’s June sales trend was only down 10%, indicating that sales are beginning to recover and moving in the direction of current expectations.  With Pizza Hut’s June same-store sales coming in at 6%, it is clear that the brand continues to build momentum.  Although the KFC numbers leave much to be desired, the comps appear to have bottomed out earlier this quarter.  Same-store sales have improved over the course of the quarter, moving from down 26% in April to down 13% in June.  We believe that China is on track for flat to positive same-store sales trends coming out of 3Q13 and positive trends early in 4Q13.    

 

YUM: THE WORST IS OVER - pen1

 

 

Rest of the World


The YRI and U.S. segments of the business continue to be solid performers and contribute to YUM’s growth profile.

 

YUM’s YRI Division reported 1% same-store sales growth, led by 5% same-store sales growth in emerging markets.  This performance was somewhat offset by weakness in the developed regions where same-store sales fell 1%.  

  • Emerging markets system sales grew 12%, driven by 8% unit growth and 5% same-store sales growth.
  • Developed markets system sales grew 1%, driven by 1% unit growth; this number was partially offset by a 1% decline in same-store sales due to weakness in Japan and the UK.
  • Restaurant margin increased 0.8% and operating profit grew 12% in the region.
  • YRI is on track for a record amount of openings this year and continues to benefit from recent asset sales.
  • Opened 205 new units in 50 countries, including 129 new units in emerging markets.

 

YUM’s U.S. Division reported 1% same-store sales growth, led by 2% and 3% same-store sales growth at Taco Bell and KFC, respectively.  Taco Bell continues to be one of the strongest brands in the QSR segment.  The brand was able to increase same-store sales despite facing a 13% comparison from last year.  Same-store sales fell 2% at Pizza Hut in the second quarter. 

  • USA same-store sales increased 1%.
  • Taco Bell same-store sales increased 2%.
  • KFC same-store sales increased 3%.
  • Pizza Hut same-store sales decreased 2%.
  • Restaurant Margin improved 0.8%.
  • Operating profit increased 4%.

 

YUM: THE WORST IS OVER - Taco Bell SSS

 

YUM: THE WORST IS OVER - KFC SSS

 

YUM: THE WORST IS OVER - Pizza Hut SSS 

 

 

Valuation


Similar to the rest of the restaurant industry, YUM’s valuation appears stretched.  We intend to issue a report card on YUM’s road to recovery as the company continues to report monthly same-store sales trends in China.  YUM’s long-term development plans in China remain intact, particularly as the company begins to focus on establishing Pizza Hut locations in lower tier cities.  We believe that the Street will soon shift its focus away from the recent negative results in China and will begin to focus on 2014 and the timing of a margin recovery.

 

 

YUM: THE WORST IS OVER - YUM EV EBITDA

 

YUM: THE WORST IS OVER - YUM PE

 

 

 

Howard Penney

Managing Director

HPenney@hedgeye.com

 

 


LVS 2Q 2013 REPORT CARD

In an effort to evaluate performance and as a follow up to our YouTube, we compare how the quarter measured up to previous management commentary and guidance


 

OVERALL

  • IN-LINE:  Low hold in Vegas and Singapore prevented LVS from meeting our estimates. While management was bullish about Macau, they were more subdued regarding the outlook for Vegas and Singapore

LVS 2Q 2013 REPORT CARD - l1

 

MACAU

 

VENETIAN TABLE YIELD

  • BETTER:  win per table per day reached almost $17,000 (21% YoY) even as average tables grew by 74 
  • PREVIOUSLY:  "We're yielding at the Venetian $12,000-plus a table last quarter. Obviously, we need more tables going forward. Even if we're doing 400 tables, we probably could use another 50 or 100. The junket yields are just down across the market because no matter who you are, you're not getting the yield per table. But we just simply follow the trends. It's hard to predict, but the good news is the government's very helpful, allowing you to move tables around."

PARISIAN OPENING DATE

  • SAME:  Parisian is on track to open in late 2015
  • PREVIOUSLY:  "Based on our current construction schedule and subject to timely government approvals, we're still targeting the opening of The Parisian for late 2015."

SINGAPORE 

 

VIP

  • BETTER:  VIP volumes grew 25% YoY.  Mgmt attributed the strong performance to $1MM bets.
  • PREVIOUSLY:  "Our VIP business remains okay. I mean, we did have a great quarter, $18 billion, but we always tell people it's a very concentrated segment that you can't predict quarter-to-quarter. It's $1,000 – $2,000 accounts that really matter in that segment. So, it's highly concentrated."

MASS WIN RATE

  • SLIGHTLY WORSE:  Mass win per day declined slightly YoY to $4.51MM 
  • PREVIOUSLY:  "We'd like to target to get that mass market business back up to about $4.6MM or more a day."

MALL

  • WORSE: mall revenues fell 4% YoY.  As more retail opens up, mgmt believes occupancy should improve.
  • PREVIOUSLY:  "The mall continues to get better and better, and we leased that during a rather difficult time. And as we keep changing out tenants, that gets better by the day and that's a wild asset. The upside of that mall, I think, is yet to be seen."

SLOTS

  • SAME:  slot handle was flat as the market continues to be pressured by govt restrictions on local play
  • PREVIOUSLY:  "Slot segment continued to show weakness. And that's because Slots is primarily driven by the local market, which has not recovered."

JAPAN

  • SAME:  expects a bill in November.  There may be a restriction that limits the time to build the new casino to two years.
  • PREVIOUSLY:  "There's a lot of noise about Japan, about 100 people in the legislature wanting to get legislation as early as November."

LVS 2Q CONFERENCE CALL NOTES

In-line quarter after adjusting for Singapore low hold. Management very bullish on Macau

 

 

CONF CALL NOTES

  • 4.6 million visits to Sands China, 40% increase YoY
  • 2Q Macau VIP RC share 17.4% vs 14.8% year ago
  • Venetian Macau leads in Macau visitation 
  • Sands Cotai Central visitation (40,000 visits per day) increased 142% YoY
  • Parisian Macau substructure under construction; based on timely govt approvals, timing for opening is late 2015
  • Korea still has potential
  • Madrid - still need govt approvals and finalization of land grants

Q & A

 

Macau

  • SCC ramp up:  big driver was mass business; cross-traffic between SCC and Venetian continues to build; 
  • SCC hotel occ lower yoy:  as they get more retail, occupancy should increase
  • Four Seasons condo sales:  lining up project mgmt and sales team; no further govt approvals needed
  • Consumer trends:  going in right direction; macro concerns in China not affecting Macau 
  • Junket operators extending credit? Does not believe strong VIP growth is driven by credit
  • Mass table yields:  flattish even as number of mass tables increases; will keep on adding mass tables 
  • Slot ETG yields declining as number of ETGs decline; still believe $1BN ETG market as an aggregate
  • Four Seasons:  transitionary period; moving into premium-mass, direct play business  
  • Better infrastructure driving Macau visitation growth; excited about HK-Zhuhai-Macau bridge
  • Labor shortages?  No.

Singapore

  • Low Singapore hold %:  5th quarter below 'average' - no concerns about that; will go back to 2.85% over time
  • VIP Volume:  $1MM bets are contributing to the strong volume; still same source of customers (mainly Mainland China/Hong Kong); 
  • Slot ETG: govt more restrictive of local play; have been challenging (less S'pore visitation offset by more visitation by Mainland Chinese, Indonesian); remains confident there will be some growth there

Other

  • Las Vegas needs to grow ADR, optimistic on 2014; gaming dependent on high-end Asian players; slot/table businesses have been 'mediocre'
    • CZR has been undercutting LVS, WYNN in room rates
  • CFO search:  in final stages
  • Japan:  gaming bill will be submitted in November; there may be a limit where the casino has to be built in two years

GET THE HEDGEYE MARKET BRIEF FREE

Enter your email address to receive our newsletter of 5 trending market topics. VIEW SAMPLE

By joining our email marketing list you agree to receive marketing emails from Hedgeye. You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in one of the emails.

RAI Results Mention E-Cigs and The FDA on Menthol

On what continues to be nasty volume trends across the cigarette industry, RAI reported relatively solid results in Q2. Despite volume declines of -6% (above the industry average of -6.1%) and RAI's total market share down 0.3% to 26% versus the prior-year quarter, the company was able to offset volume declines by pricing and strong performance from Camel and Pall Mall, its two growth brands in the premium and value categories, respectively, and positive results from Camel SNUS (80% market share) and moist-snuff leader Grizzly that saw brand share up 1.0% in the quarter.

 

We’re optimistic on RAI’s 2H performance due to the migration and growth of smokeless tobacco and e-cigs as contributing factors offsetting declining cigarette volume trends and tougher comps in the back half of 2013.

 

We do expect cigarette volume declines to persist. The company expects volumes to decline 4-5% for the year and cited such contributing factors as: ongoing weakness in the economy, high unemployment, higher retail prices, and tougher comps given lower volume declines last year (-2.3%), and growth in smokeless tobacco and smoke-free technologies like electronic cigarettes (e-cigs).

 

 

On e-cigs: the company looks to continue to invest in its e-cig brand VUSE in the back half.  Interestingly, it opened its earnings call by underling that it’s excited that VUSE is expanding into its first major market, Colorado. In the Q&A, the company noted that VUSE will grow to have a commanding presence in the e-cig market, already out in 500 retail stores in the first week, with a flavor profile it calls superior to its competitors.

 

On industry trends, it claims it’s too early to talk about the consumer response, but said retailers are extremely positive. It noted that while e-cigs have strong trialing, so far the conversion is low. RAI also said that while its products may have product displays at retail that are available to the customer, it’s a clerk-assisted sale with the actual product housed behind the counter.

 

 

On Menthols and the FDA: Yesterday the FDA released a second review on menthol cigarettes that essentially reached the same conclusion of its first: menthol cigarettes appeal disproportionately to younger smokers and are more addictive than other cigarettes. This is noteworthy given that one-third of RAI’s total cigarette volume is menthol.

 

RAI took numerous questions on its outlook and strategy given the announcement, but its only main response was it will continue to review the proposed rule making before responding. 

 

In response to the first report, Big Tobacco filed its own report with the FDA, making the case that menthols pose no different risk to public health than any other cigarette and therefore should not be subject to special regulation. It also sued the FDA over the experts it had appointed to the Tobacco Products Scientific Advisory Committee tasked with the 2011 study.

 

We’ll be monitoring both the regulatory and company actions in response to this release.

 

 

Results: On the quarter, EPS beat consensus by one cent at $0.84. Revenue was lighter at $2.18B vs the Street at $2.19B, and increased 0.1% versus the prior-year quarter. RAI repurchased 3.1 million shares for $150MM.  On the year, RAI reaffirmed EPS ex-items of $3.15-3.30.

 

 

Matthew Hedrick

Senior Analyst


China: Dour Indeed

Consistent with our recent work, the Chinese growth outlook for the remainder of the year appears rather dour indeed.

 

China: Dour Indeed - China PMI

 

This is evidenced by this morning’s data, which showed manufacturing growth hitting an 11-month low in July. Asian markets were mostly lower on the news, with the Shanghai Composite falling 1.3%.

 

The consensus response (i.e. “Must… Stimulate… Now…”) remains largely offsides. Pulling forward railway construction won’t move the needle on Chinese growth. In reality, all it does is create a vacuum of reduced outlays to muddle through on the back-end. 

 

Still, we don’t want to be short anything that even remotely resembles a stimulus package. The buy-side is trained to buy stimulus now, and ask questions later.

 


RCL YOUTUBE

In preparation for RCL's F2Q 2013 earnings release tomorrow, we’ve put together the recent pertinent forward looking company commentary.

 

 

YOUTUBE FROM Q1 CONFERENCE CALL

  • "The higher ticket yields were driven by Caribbean, Brazil and Asia itineraries."
  • "We saw improvement in all categories for onboard revenue. Ships that have been recently revitalized and vessels sailing on new itineraries did particularly well."
  • "We believe marketing spend is key to driving higher revenues and expect to invest these savings throughout the balance of the year."
  • "Over the last few weeks though, we have seen an improvement in booking activity and we are still forecasting record yields for the Caribbean."
  • "Our average lead pricing is currently about 3% higher than the same time last year for sailings departing within the next 12 months."
  • "On average, our guests are booking their cruise about two weeks earlier this year than they were in 2011 and 2012. In fact, the booking curve has looked strikingly similar to 2008 for the last several months."
  • "We will have more Americans cruising with us on itineraries away from North America in 2013 than we had expected. Conversely, we will have more guests from outside North America cruising with us in the Caribbean in 2013 than we had expected."
  • "We considered our European summer revenue projections to have more risks attached to them in comparison to other spheres of deployment. Although there is still somewhat limited visibility for all of our summer deployment, at this juncture, in Europe, we are sufficiently ahead of 2012 on both rate and occupancy, to be comfortable that our European deployment is of comparable risk to our other programs."
  • "Turning to China, the region that represents 5% of our capacity in 2013. The hostility between Japan and China surrounding the disputed islands in the East China Sea continues to affect our itineraries and our demand generation. We have now removed the Japanese ports of call from nearly all of 2013's North Asia program. As a result, most itineraries from our China homeport of Shanghai and Tianjin are calling only on ports of call on South Korea."
  • "You're going to continue to see promotions by us. You're going to see them by our competitors."
  • [Negative publicity] "For now, it will probably have more of an effect on potential first-timers. The problem is that people don't call us on the phone to tell us that they're not booking with us."
  • [Q3 Europe] "We had said back in early February that we were a little less than 50% booked for Europe. And today, we're around 70% booked, to give you some sense of where we are. We're still counting on more business. But the fact that we have maintained our full year guidance, despite the fact that we had a good first quarter, certainly implies that we've taken a little bit of a haircut in Q2 through Q4."
  • "The markets that I would say we're seeing the most softness in would be, of course, Spain. And then probably secondarily the UK would be a little bit weaker than maybe we would have expected. Germany has actually held up quite well for us with – particularly with our TUI Cruises brand, we're very pleased with its performance. And then the other markets, in general, seem to be doing well."
  • [Australia] "In the near-term is flat to slightly lower yield outlook for us for this year. we would expect that Australia, as a southern summer market, would continue to grow and be a mainstay of the cruise industry going forward."
  • "Pullmantur's performance is inevitably affected by that [Spain] very strongly and that's been a big disappointment and I don't see any quick turn away from massive improvement given the economic situation."
  • "The French, the CDF, Croisières de France, situation is actually doing quite well for us. And we would expect to continue to expand that to take advantage of a good market position."

Early Look

daily macro intelligence

Relied upon by big institutional and individual investors across the world, this granular morning newsletter distills the latest and most vital market developments and insures that you are always in the know.

next