• Investing Insights & Exclusive Offers → Get Our FREE “Market Brief”
    Sign-up for our free weekly newsletter. Get unparalleled investing insights and exclusive Summer Sale discounts on Hedgeye research.

    Disclaimer: By joining our email marketing list you agree to receive marketing emails from Hedgeye. You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in one of the emails. Use of Hedgeye and any other products available through hedgeye.com are subject to our Terms Of Service and Privacy Policy

Singh and the INC have been handed an overwhelming mandate, now comes the hard part...

Research Edge Position: Short the Indian Equity Market via IFN

"Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's electoral victory, the biggest any Indian politician has scored in two decades, may loosen political shackles that have restrained the country's economic growth as it struggles to free half a billion people from poverty"  Bloomberg,  May 18

The INC victory announced over the weekend has been received by voters, investors and the global media with near boundless enthusiasm that Prime Minister Singh -the 76 year old architect of the economic miracle of India's recent decade of growth, will now, allegedly, be able to affect dramatic changes with his new mandate and get the subcontinent back on track to resume breakneck growth levels.

The market response to this absolutely ripped our face off when the Sensex spiked upwards by 17% on the open before trading was halted, only to trigger an automatic trading halt upon reopening two hours later.

 India: Optimism Triumphant - indiasenex

The INC and it's close allies have won the most decisive victory in national election that India has seen in decades with 261 of the 543 lower house seats squarely under their control -a massive percentage in the fractured universe of Indian political parties. Singh's administration will know be able to throw off the fetters of previous coalitions which required compromise with hard core leftist parties.

For Singh, the top priorities now include new programs to reduce rural poverty, finding new lending partners to support increased government spending and building a dialogue with the Obama administration to continue the advances made with Bush team on trade -most notably the civilian nuclear program.

At heart, the Singh vision of emerging Indian strength is based on the belief that the country can move forward socially -elevating the majority of the nation's population from grinding agricultural poverty, while largely skipping the industrial phase of development that other emerging economies like China and Brazil embrace. The single biggest criticism of Singh's policies by the left has been that the economic miracle of the past ten years was not felt directly by the poor -with the fastest growth instead largely concentrated in the high tech service industry hubs like Calcutta where job creation has been limited to the well educated and well born.  Without a globally competitive industrial presence, skilled labor job creation for the lower classes has been limited to what internal demand can support - e.g. a nascent automobile industry.

Whether this model works - a thriving minority capable of supporting the social cost of handouts to keep an impoverished majority docile until real change ultimately arrives, remains to be seen.  My immediate suspicion is that only by creating competitive export manufacturing industries can the Indian economy create the kind of jobs that will portion of the nation's poor that are economically enfranchised and build meaningful internal demand.

Poverty eradication, however, is not what emerging markets investing is all about: ultimately the name of the game for a savvy emerging market investor is holding your nose while you try to buy monster growth multiples.  Show me an emerging markets PM talking up social justice and I'll show you a man trying to justify underwater long positions.

While we can appreciate that approach (particularly today!) we still can't rectify the INC strategy with the kind of long term growth that could bring hundreds of millions economically empowered consumers online and build internal demand in the coming years, or with a competitive stance for the global manufactured product export markets. 

In the immediate term, the bulls are winning in a major way. Beyond a technical pull back in the face of today's rally, the biggest near term negative market catalyst I see is currency strength. The Rupee rose +3% in the election afterglow, achieving its highest levels YTD. Presumably, if this TREND continues, it will dampen investor euphoria for tech service sector names.

Andrew Barber