CHART OF THE DAY: Foot Soldiers Or Generals?


CHART OF THE DAY: Foot Soldiers Or Generals? - Chart of the Day

Foot Soldiers Or Generals?

“His outward appearance seemed indifferent and unconcerned over the wretchedness of his soldiers…although French and Allies shouted into his ears many oaths and curses about his own guilty person, he was still able to listen to them unmoved.”

-Jakob Walter, German soldier under Napoleon


Two hundred years ago, following one of the most brutal military campaigns in history, thousands of young European men traipsed through the snow of East Prussia, half-dead.  The Diary of a Napoleonic Foot Soldier, by Jakob Walter, is a harrowing but thoroughly enjoyable account of what it was like to serve in Napoleon’s Grand Armée during the ill-fated invasion of Russia in June 1812.  Given that one is as likely to be born in one country, at one time, as another country at another time, I am particularly grateful I was not one of the 600,000 Napoleonic soldiers that crossed into Russia in mid-1812.  Of the 140,000 that were left to retreat from Moscow, only 25,000 actually crossed back over the border in December 1812 to begin the long walk home.


Few individuals have left as indelible a mark on history as Napoleon Bonaparte.   That he was born in Corsica of Italian heritage but went on to gain the title “Emperor of the French” is indicative of the strength of personality he possessed.  All of his courage and decisiveness meant little without the contribution of his subjects.  Napoleon understood this; it is estimated that between 1800 and 1815, he raised approximately two million conscripts, or 7% of the population, in France alone.   Was the future of 18th Century France (or 1930’s Germany or Russia) dictated by the common man’s wishes or a charismatic leader dragging a country toward his vision?  This question has no definitive answer but it can serve as a loose metaphor for policy versus demographics in our contemporary economy.  While demography is concerned with the passive role people play in economies, the roles of the common man and policy maker in driving economic growth are important to consider in 2013.  Harry Dent, author of several books on demographics and its importance states: “it’s Homer Simpson that drives our economy, not Ben Bernanke or Barack Obama!”


I recently did some long overdue reading on demography.  While my understanding of the subject is tenuous at best, it is clear to me that understanding the role of demographic and technology cycles is key to understanding what drives our economy over the long term.  Hedgeye Healthcare Sector Head Tom Tobin and his team have produced some excellent research that anchors off these topics.  Recently, his work has suggested that household formation, maternity, and pet ownership (WOOF) rest on a similar age demographic and are likely to see corresponding strength.  While the increasingly short-term nature of our industry has marginalized such thought processes, we continue to believe that identifying investment themes that deviate from consensus but are supported by long-term cycles can lead to highly actionable ideas.


Considering some of the key demographic trends pertaining to the consumer economy offers interesting long-term insights.  In terms of the sector my team covers, restaurants, the core demographic of casual dining companies tends to be the 45-65 YOA cohort.  For any consumer industry executive, decelerating population growth among age cohorts with a high propensity to spend money on your goods or services will act as a top-line headwind.  Pertaining to the restaurant industry, it is clear that for many years executives’ lives were made easier by a rising demographic tide.  We believe that casual dining is facing a painful adjustment due to excessive unit growth.  Trading opportunities on the long side will remain, on immediate-to-intermediate-term bases, but we see casual dining as a group that will experience consolidation for a number of years.  It is no coincidence that the management teams that are most demonstratively aware of the demographic headwind are running the companies whose shares we are relatively positive on (EAT – at a price).  Darden Restaurants (DRI) is one company that we became bearish on in July.  One of the key issues we took with management’s strategy was its growth trajectory and we continue to believe that it is overly aggressive relative to the fundamental performance of its chains and the overall health of the industry.  The quote, below, from Brinker (EAT) CEO, Guy Constant, highlights the reality of the situation facing his industry and his company’s awareness of it:


“…We've had to deal with those questions internally because as a company that's only ever been in a growth space, it's been an adjustment for us to adjust to running a business in a more mature space now than we did before. But knowing then that history, we believe, is repeating itself, that helps you understand what you need to do in order to survive in this space.”


While long-term demographic and technology cycles dictate economic growth, from an investment perspective, it is self-evident that policy has a significant impact on market prices as well as the duration and amplitude of economic cycles.  The market, after all, is not the economy.  Previously, I have wondered if forming an opinion on government policy is a worthwhile exercise.  Long-term cycles seem to bear out over time regardless of government policies (give or take a few years).  In recent times, our macro team’s process of focusing on Growth, Inflation, and Policy has proven effective in identifying key inflection points in markets, globally.  Moreover, the level of government intervention in markets implores investors to form an opinion on policy and to update it, regularly.  For example, investors in gold that have ignored policy, and the expectations around it, have had a difficult time of late. 


Our view of policy makers in the US (and almost everywhere else) has been decidedly negative.  Keith wrote in yesterday’s Early Look: “What if Bernanke is what he usually is – wrong on his growth forecasts? What if unemployment rate expectations start to fall towards 6.5% in 2013 instead of in 2017? Inquiring Bond and Gold bulls would like to know…”  Yesterday we saw gold and bonds get crushed on the expectation that Bernanke could be forced to call back his troops if expectations of employment growth improve sufficiently.  Every general meets his Waterloo.  The only question is when.


Timing, as always, is the critical factor in investing but even more so in life.  After all, if not for timing, we could have been Napoleonic foot soldiers.


Have a great weekend,


Rory Green

Senior Analyst


Foot Soldiers Or Generals? - Chart of the Day


Foot Soldiers Or Generals? - Virtual Portfolio


Today we shorted EZ CORP (EZPW) at $20.15 a share at 3:19 PM EDT in our Real-Time Alerts. Along with Cash America (CSH), EZ CORP will be one of the pawn shop operators affected by gold’s recent downturn. When gold falls, it takes pawns down with it. We remain bearish on the stock through Q1 2013.




real-time alerts

real edge in real-time

This indispensable trading tool is based on a risk management signaling process Hedgeye CEO Keith McCullough developed during his years as a hedge fund manager and continues to refine. Nearly every trading day, you’ll receive Keith’s latest signals - buy, sell, short or cover.

MNST - Buying Mispriced Growth

When we initiated coverage of the consumer staples sector a couple of weeks back, we highlighted two "broken" growth stories as being interesting - MJN (+5.9% since 12/17) and MNST (-1.4%).  Admittedly, MJN's market share and pricing issues in China were easier to get comfort with versus the more open-ended spectre of the possible regulation of energy drinks, but we see the outcomes as ultimately being the same - investors will go back to paying a premium multiple for the underlying growth profile in both stories.


It is our belief that the FDA has as much business regulating energy drinks as we do - which is to say, right around no business at all.  And while the timing of a likely favorable outcome is unclear, we believe that investors will be rewarded for picking their spots in this name, as we did today.


MNST - Buying Mispriced Growth - MNST Mispriced


MNST - Buying Mispriced Growth - MNST T T



Robert  Campagnino

Managing Director




OZM: Leading The Pack

Och-Ziff Capital Management (OZM), one of the few publicly traded hedge funds on the market, crushed December with their Master Fund gaining 1.0% month-over-month, ending 2012 up 11.18%. Their European Master Fund and Asia Master Fund were up 8.62% and 7.07% for 2012, respectively. Compared with the benchmark HFRX Global Hedge Fund Index 2012 return of 3.17%, OZM had a killer year.


OZM: Leading The Pack  - OZMchart


Though fund flows (money going into the fund) were negative for December by ~$450 million, they were positive for the year at $300 million. We expect more inflows into Och-Ziff in 2013 based on last year’s strong performance numbers. 


The stock is one of our top long ideas in financials for 2013. We believe that the market has yet to recognize the value of OZM’s incentive fee business and now that the fiscal cliff is behind us, we see that there is no damaging regulation that will affect asset management firms save for the small bump in long-term capital gains rates. It’s also worth noting that alternative asset managers like hedge funds do well in times of quantitative easing and we are well into our third round of QE.

get free cartoon of the day!

Start receiving Hedgeye's Cartoon of the Day, an exclusive and humourous take on the market and the economy, delivered every morning to your inbox

By joining our email marketing list you agree to receive marketing emails from Hedgeye. You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in one of the emails.