prev

BREAKING DOWN THE US GDP REPORT

Takeaway: With a pre-election boost in government spending comes heightened odds that US GDP growth slows demonstrably in 4Q12/1Q13.

This note was originally published October 26, 2012 at 11:23 in Macro

SUMMARY BULLETS:

 

  • On an industry-standard C+I+G+NX (C=consumption, I=investment, G=government and NX=net exports) basis, the 3Q12 GDP report was not good. The underlying trends suggest the odds of US recession over the intermediate term are now much higher than they were a 8:29am EST.
  • The unsustainable uptick in government spending ahead of the election portends quite negatively for 4Q12/1Q13 real GDP growth. Without Uncle Sam’s pre-election encroachment, 3Q12 US real GDP growth would have came in at +1.3% QoQ SAAR – or unchanged from 2Q12. If “G” actually came in at the trailing four quarter average of its contribution to GDP, 3Q12 US real GDP growth would have been a paltry +0.9% QoQ SAAR.
  • Imports contributed +4bps to the headline GDP figure of +2% on the strength of a sequential contraction of -0.2% (down from +2.8% QoQ in 2Q12). This is the first sequential contraction of US imports since 2Q09. Importantly, the slowdown in import growth portends somewhat negatively for domestic demand trends over the intermediate term. Imports, which themselves are led by orders, lead real final sales. We’ve highlighted this relationship in previous notes (click here for more details). Is a disappointing holiday season on the horizon?
  • Furthermore, the 3Q12 GDP report suggests weak imports may be leading a sequential slowdown in both “C” and “I”  in the upcoming quarter(s). Additionally, an demonstrable and unsustainable acceleration  in “G” was all that stood in the way of a -35% deceleration to +0.9% QoQ SAAR, allowing the headline figure to come in at +2% QoQ SAAR. This means that growth is trending along a +0.9% QoQ SAAR run rate and potentially headed lower if “C” and “I” exhibits signs of slowing.
  • Unfortunately, dual slowing of “C” and “I” is indeed a probable scenario, given the uncertainty surrounding the election, fiscal cliff and debt ceiling breach. Moreover, each catalyst may actually be contributing to a noteworthy acceleration in corporate cost-cutting initiatives (layoffs?), as highlighted on 3Q earnings calls. Recessions happen when baseline GROWTH is weak, the corporate earnings cycle slows and companies start trying to cut their way into meeting peak-cycle, peak-margin forward EPS estimates. In this respect, 4Q12 is very much like 4Q07.

 

On a SAAR basis, US real GDP growth accelerated to +2% QoQ in 3Q12 from +1.3% in 2Q12; on a YoY basis, US real GDP growth accelerated to +2.3% in 3Q12 from +2.1% in 2Q12.

 

Looking beyond the headline figures, there were some rather interesting occurrences that we think are worth highlighting:

 

  • Driven by a demonstrable acceleration in federal government spending (+9.6% QoQ in 3Q12 from -0.2% in 2Q12) the “G” in the C+I+G+NX equation contributed +71bps (or 36%) to the +2% headline figure. This was the first quarter “G” posted a positive contribution to the headline figure since 2Q10. Like the SEP Unemployment Rate and the OCT UofMich Consumer Confidence Index, the 3Q12 GDP report is just strong enough for President Obama to claim he’s got the US economy back on track just in time for the election.
  • Driven by a -1.3% QoQ decline, business investment (i.e. nonresidential fixed investment) was net drag of -13bps on the headline GDP figure of +2%; this is the first time we’ve seen US businesses retrench since 1Q11, when a -1.3% QoQ contraction then contributed to a net drag of -11bps on the then-headline +0.1% QoQ SAAR figure. Uncertainty over the domestic political situation continues to contribute to slow economic growth. More on this later.
  • Driven largely by drought-induced weakness in farm inventories, inventories overall contributed a -12bps drag on the headline GDP figure of +2%; this is up sequentially from -46bps. Nonfarm inventories contributed +30bps to the headline GDP figure, while farm inventories contributed a -42bps drag.
  • The much-celebrated recovery in the housing market continues to auger positive for domestic real GDP growth, contributing +33bps to the headline figure in 3Q12 (up from a +19bps contribution in 2Q12) on the strength of a +14.4% QoQ growth rate (accelerated from +8.5% QoQ in 2Q12).

 

BREAKING DOWN THE US GDP REPORT - 1

 

Given that we’re well into 4Q12 already, we think it’s worth highlighting a few nuggets from the 3Q12 report that may offer clues as to where the rate of domestic GROWTH might end up in the current and proceeding quarters:

 

  • Imports contributed +4bps to the headline GDP figure of +2% on the strength of a sequential contraction of -0.2% (down from +2.8% QoQ in 2Q12). This is the first sequential contraction of US imports since 2Q09. Importantly, the slowdown in import growth portends somewhat negatively for domestic demand trends over the intermediate term. Imports, which themselves are led by orders, lead real final sales. We’ve highlighted this relationship in previous notes (click here for more details). Is a disappointing holiday season on the horizon?
  • The unsustainable uptick in government spending ahead of the election – as great as it may be for the Keynesian elite – actually portends quite negatively for 4Q12/1Q13 real GDP growth. Without Uncle Sam’s pre-election encroachment, 3Q12 US real GDP growth would have came in at +1.3% QoQ SAAR – or unchanged from 2Q12. If “G” actually came in at the trailing four quarter average of its contribution to GDP, 3Q12 US real GDP growth would have been a paltry +0.9% QoQ SAAR. Imagine if three months from now, US real GDP slowed from +2% QoQ SAAR in 3Q12 to +0.9% QoQ SAAR (or lower) in 4Q12. That is a real risk.

 

BREAKING DOWN THE US GDP REPORT - 2

 

Net-net, the 3Q12 GDP report suggests weak imports may be leading a sequential slowdown in both “C” and “I”  in the upcoming quarter(s). Additionally, an demonstrable and unsustainable acceleration  in “G” was all that stood in the way of a -35% deceleration to +0.9% QoQ SAAR, allowing the headline figure to come in at +2% QoQ SAAR. This means that growth is trending along a +0.9% QoQ SAAR run rate and potentially headed lower if “C” and “I” exhibits signs of slowing.

 

Unfortunately, dual slowing of “C” and “I” is indeed a probable scenario, given the uncertainty surrounding the election, fiscal cliff and debt ceiling breach. Moreover, each catalyst may actually be contributing to a noteworthy acceleration in corporate cost-cutting initiatives (layoffs?), as highlighted on 3Q earnings calls. Recessions happen when baseline GROWTH is weak, the corporate earnings cycle slows and companies start trying to cut their way into meeting peak-cycle, peak-margin forward EPS estimates. In this respect, 4Q12 is very much like its 2007 counterpart.

 

Our updated US GIP model is included in the chart below.

 

Darius Dale

Senior Analyst

 

BREAKING DOWN THE US GDP REPORT - US LOW


Casual Dining Downturn

How bearish can you be on a particular sector? As far as we’re concerned, we’re as bearish as can be on casual dining. The consensus is far too bullish on top-line trends and earnings season is suggesting that companies are in worse shape than previously thought. Anemic real wage growth is just one of many macroeconomic headwinds involved with casual dining.

 

The Restaurant Value Spread is suggesting that inflation at restaurants is outstripping inflation at grocery stores and may have an adverse impact on same-restaurant sales growth this year. As you can see in the chart below, things are heading lower and lower; clearly Street estimates are overdue for a revision.

 

Casual Dining Downturn  - casual dining RVS


BREAKING DOWN THE US GDP REPORT: THE ODDS OF A RECESSION JUST INCREASED

Takeaway: With a pre-election boost in government spending comes heightened odds that US GDP growth slows demonstrably in 4Q12/1Q13.

SUMMARY BULLETS:

 

  • On an industry-standard C+I+G+NX (C=consumption, I=investment, G=government and NX=net exports) basis, the 3Q12 GDP report was not good. The underlying trends suggest the odds of US recession over the intermediate term are now much higher than they were a 8:29am EST.
  • The unsustainable uptick in government spending ahead of the election portends quite negatively for 4Q12/1Q13 real GDP growth. Without Uncle Sam’s pre-election encroachment, 3Q12 US real GDP growth would have came in at +1.3% QoQ SAAR – or unchanged from 2Q12. If “G” actually came in at the trailing four quarter average of its contribution to GDP, 3Q12 US real GDP growth would have been a paltry +0.9% QoQ SAAR.
  • Imports contributed +4bps to the headline GDP figure of +2% on the strength of a sequential contraction of -0.2% (down from +2.8% QoQ in 2Q12). This is the first sequential contraction of US imports since 2Q09. Importantly, the slowdown in import growth portends somewhat negatively for domestic demand trends over the intermediate term. Imports, which themselves are led by orders, lead real final sales. We’ve highlighted this relationship in previous notes (click here for more details). Is a disappointing holiday season on the horizon?
  • Furthermore, the 3Q12 GDP report suggests weak imports may be leading a sequential slowdown in both “C” and “I”  in the upcoming quarter(s). Additionally, an demonstrable and unsustainable acceleration  in “G” was all that stood in the way of a -35% deceleration to +0.9% QoQ SAAR, allowing the headline figure to come in at +2% QoQ SAAR. This means that growth is trending along a +0.9% QoQ SAAR run rate and potentially headed lower if “C” and “I” exhibits signs of slowing.
  • Unfortunately, dual slowing of “C” and “I” is indeed a probable scenario, given the uncertainty surrounding the election, fiscal cliff and debt ceiling breach. Moreover, each catalyst may actually be contributing to a noteworthy acceleration in corporate cost-cutting initiatives (layoffs?), as highlighted on 3Q earnings calls. Recessions happen when baseline GROWTH is weak, the corporate earnings cycle slows and companies start trying to cut their way into meeting peak-cycle, peak-margin forward EPS estimates. In this respect, 4Q12 is very much like 4Q07.

 

On a SAAR basis, US real GDP growth accelerated to +2% QoQ in 3Q12 from +1.3% in 2Q12; on a YoY basis, US real GDP growth accelerated to +2.3% in 3Q12 from +2.1% in 2Q12.

 

Looking beyond the headline figures, there were some rather interesting occurrences that we think are worth highlighting:

 

  • Driven by a demonstrable acceleration in federal government spending (+9.6% QoQ in 3Q12 from -0.2% in 2Q12) the “G” in the C+I+G+NX equation contributed +71bps (or 36%) to the +2% headline figure. This was the first quarter “G” posted a positive contribution to the headline figure since 2Q10. Like the SEP Unemployment Rate and the OCT UofMich Consumer Confidence Index, the 3Q12 GDP report is just strong enough for President Obama to claim he’s got the US economy back on track just in time for the election.
  • Driven by a -1.3% QoQ decline, business investment (i.e. nonresidential fixed investment) was net drag of -13bps on the headline GDP figure of +2%; this is the first time we’ve seen US businesses retrench since 1Q11, when a -1.3% QoQ contraction then contributed to a net drag of -11bps on the then-headline +0.1% QoQ SAAR figure. Uncertainty over the domestic political situation continues to contribute to slow economic growth. More on this later.
  • Driven largely by drought-induced weakness in farm inventories, inventories overall contributed a -12bps drag on the headline GDP figure of +2%; this is up sequentially from -46bps. Nonfarm inventories contributed +30bps to the headline GDP figure, while farm inventories contributed a -42bps drag.
  • The much-celebrated recovery in the housing market continues to auger positive for domestic real GDP growth, contributing +33bps to the headline figure in 3Q12 (up from a +19bps contribution in 2Q12) on the strength of a +14.4% QoQ growth rate (accelerated from +8.5% QoQ in 2Q12).

 

BREAKING DOWN THE US GDP REPORT: THE ODDS OF A RECESSION JUST INCREASED - 1

 

Given that we’re well into 4Q12 already, we think it’s worth highlighting a few nuggets from the 3Q12 report that may offer clues as to where the rate of domestic GROWTH might end up in the current and proceeding quarters:

 

  • Imports contributed +4bps to the headline GDP figure of +2% on the strength of a sequential contraction of -0.2% (down from +2.8% QoQ in 2Q12). This is the first sequential contraction of US imports since 2Q09. Importantly, the slowdown in import growth portends somewhat negatively for domestic demand trends over the intermediate term. Imports, which themselves are led by orders, lead real final sales. We’ve highlighted this relationship in previous notes (click here for more details). Is a disappointing holiday season on the horizon?
  • The unsustainable uptick in government spending ahead of the election – as great as it may be for the Keynesian elite – actually portends quite negatively for 4Q12/1Q13 real GDP growth. Without Uncle Sam’s pre-election encroachment, 3Q12 US real GDP growth would have came in at +1.3% QoQ SAAR – or unchanged from 2Q12. If “G” actually came in at the trailing four quarter average of its contribution to GDP, 3Q12 US real GDP growth would have been a paltry +0.9% QoQ SAAR. Imagine if three months from now, US real GDP slowed from +2% QoQ SAAR in 3Q12 to +0.9% QoQ SAAR (or lower) in 4Q12. That is a real risk.

 

BREAKING DOWN THE US GDP REPORT: THE ODDS OF A RECESSION JUST INCREASED - 2

 

Net-net, the 3Q12 GDP report suggests weak imports may be leading a sequential slowdown in both “C” and “I”  in the upcoming quarter(s). Additionally, an demonstrable and unsustainable acceleration  in “G” was all that stood in the way of a -35% deceleration to +0.9% QoQ SAAR, allowing the headline figure to come in at +2% QoQ SAAR. This means that growth is trending along a +0.9% QoQ SAAR run rate and potentially headed lower if “C” and “I” exhibits signs of slowing.

 

Unfortunately, dual slowing of “C” and “I” is indeed a probable scenario, given the uncertainty surrounding the election, fiscal cliff and debt ceiling breach. Moreover, each catalyst may actually be contributing to a noteworthy acceleration in corporate cost-cutting initiatives (layoffs?), as highlighted on 3Q earnings calls. Recessions happen when baseline GROWTH is weak, the corporate earnings cycle slows and companies start trying to cut their way into meeting peak-cycle, peak-margin forward EPS estimates. In this respect, 4Q12 is very much like its 2007 counterpart.

 

Our updated US GIP model is included in the chart below.

 

Darius Dale

Senior Analyst

 

BREAKING DOWN THE US GDP REPORT: THE ODDS OF A RECESSION JUST INCREASED - US LOW


Hedgeye Statistics

The total percentage of successful long and short trading signals since the inception of Real-Time Alerts in August of 2008.

  • LONG SIGNALS 80.32%
  • SHORT SIGNALS 78.48%

Bearish TREND: S&P 500 Levels, Refreshed

Takeaway: Our top Hedgeye Global Macro Theme for Q4 of #EarningsSlowing continues to play out at an accelerating rate.

POSITIONS: Long Utilities (XLU), Short Industrials (XLI)

 

Our top Hedgeye Global Macro Theme for Q4 of #EarningsSlowing continues to play out at an accelerating rate. Half way through Earnings Season, we see no reason to back off that fundamental research view.

 

From a quantitative perspective (different from the research view), the bearish TREND signal remains. Across our core risk management durations, here are the lines that matter to me most:

 

  1. Intermediate-term TREND resistance = 1419
  2. Immediate-term TRADE support = 1391
  3. Long-term TAIL support = 1354

 

In other words, now that the SP500 is slicing through its April 2012 highs (and there’s no Fed put), long-term TAIL support is back in play.

 

On growth, 1/3 of this morning’s GDP print came from a Government Spending (contributing +0.71% out of nowhere, after 8 consecutive quarters of declines!). That’s going to matter as the legacy media figures it out.

 

KM

 

Keith R. McCullough
Chief Executive Officer

 

Bearish TREND: S&P 500 Levels, Refreshed - SPX


The Romney USD/Energy Play

We hosted an expert call with Ken Bickers on the November election  this week and the outcome of his model shows Romney winning by a landslide. Romney says he would open up drilling on federal lands and offshore - that’s great for energy, right? Not really. A Romney win is bullish for the US dollar and when the dollar goes up, oil goes down; correlation is a beautiful thing.

 

From Hedgeye Energy Analyst Kevin Kaiser, here are the winners and losers if Romney wins the election:

 

  • Relative losers: crude oil E&Ps, refiners, oilfield services, renewables/clean.  Oil prices fall and Romney cuts subsidies to the renewable/clean energy companies.  Less regulation, more offshore drilling, Keystone XL, and a better tax environment are all well and good – but won’t move the stocks.
  • Relative winners: coal producers.  Romney is pro-coal, opposing looming EPA

The Romney USD/Energy Play  - energyUSD


PCAR: Simply The Best

Paccar (PCAR) remains our top long idea for the Industrials sector. The company is executing well, taking market share in a cyclically depressed industry and put up a solid quarter this week. As Navistar (NAV) struggles with customer perception of its engines and financial stability, PCAR looks to benefit from NAV’s share loss.

 

PCAR: Simply The Best - PCAR chart


real-time alerts

real edge in real-time

This indispensable trading tool is based on a risk management signaling process Hedgeye CEO Keith McCullough developed during his years as a hedge fund manager and continues to refine. Nearly every trading day, you’ll receive Keith’s latest signals - buy, sell, short or cover.

next