Not the highest quality quarter but guidance was better.



MAR remains our favorite hotel company for the long-term.  The stock has had a nice ride and could take a breather, but numbers look like they are going higher.  Absent macro deterioration – MAR more defensive but clearly not immune – the stock should continue to work over the intermediate and long term.


MAR’s Q1 results were slightly below our projections numbers but in-line with the street.  A low tax rate contributed almost $0.02 to the Q.  Here’s where the miss vs. our numbers came from: 

  • Base mgmt and franchise fees were $13MM lower (~5%)
    • Lower managed room growth – only 0.3% YoY vs. our estimate of 1.6% (3.4k less rooms were added to the system than we modeled)
    • Base fees were also negatively impacted by a $3MM reversal of fees from 2 contract revisions
  • Incentive fees were $8MM higher, up 18%
    • 29% of managed hotels paid incentive fees vs. 25% last year
  • Owned leased/other profits were in-line but revenues were lower – so basically it was in-line since top line doesn’t really matter for this line item.  We don’t know what the breakout was yet between fees vs. owned/leased
  • G&A was $3MM lower
  • The tax rate was 3.7% lower than guided rate and contributing almost $0.02 in EPS
  • Net interest expense was $7MM higher than we modeled but equity earnings loss was $4MM lower as well

Other stuff:

  • WW RevPAR was 6.8% - above the 5-6% guidance range
  • MAR bought back $150MM of stock or 4.2MM shares in the Q – we modeled $200MM
  • Provided YoY comparison on Autograph hotels for RevPAR
  • There were a lot more hotel “exits” this quarter than prior quarters – hence, lower net rooms growth 


  • Increased WW RevPAR guidance to 6-8% from 5-7%
  • Increased FY fee guidance by $15MM or 1%
  • Increased owned, leased corporate housing and other, net result by $5-10MM
  • Raised EPS guidance 5-6 cents
  • Upped capex guidance by $50MM
  • Increased EBITDA guidance by $10-25MM


Dollar strength over the past week pressured commodity prices, as the table below shows.  Corn is declining sharply and cattle prices are also yet to regain the ground lost since the “pink slime” scandal turned prices lower.  Over half of the commodities in the table below are now red in the year-over-year column.  We expect more red numbers in that column as we move through 2Q and into 3Q.  Coffee is the biggest decliner, which is a positive for the coffee players as they look to extend contracts with suppliers.  On the upside, the clear standout is chicken wings.  +125% year-over-year and headed higher.  We also think that the top-line was heavily boosted by weather in 1Q, declining from the 12.9% same-store sales growth in the first six weeks to 10.5% for the total quarter.  If 8.9% comps and +50bps COGS drove down margins year-over-year, what will ~20% COGS inflation and mid-single digit comps  do to margins?












WEN: Obviously, we're all watching gas prices carefully and – but consumers seem to quite honestly have digested that quite nicely.


BAGL: If employment continues to be positive, again from my perspective, I think that sort of offsets any impact that you might get – we might get on gas prices … That said, if employment tightens up or we don't see continuously positive momentum than longer-term, obviously, if we get a $5 gas price, that's one of those price points that hits overall.


CBRL: We think that given our susceptibility particularly to – in the summer travel season to potential increases in gasoline prices that it is appropriate to be suitably cautious about our third and fourth quarter traffic outlook.


DRI: Yes, I would say as we look back, we don't think the current levels, the $4 current gas prices, no longer represents sticker shock.


SONC: We've seen a rising employment, declining unemployment – consumer confidence has improved somewhat, but at this point, I wouldn't say that we've seen a negative impact from gas prices that we can discern.







Supply: Arabica harvests in Brazil get underway in June and good weather during growing season is fueling speculation that the country will produce a large quantity of coffee this year.  The robusta harvest in the main coffee producing state in Brazil, have started harvesting this year’s crop.


Demand: Economic concerns, particularly, in Europe, have led to concerns about demand for coffee on a global scale. While emerging markets are increasingly driving demand growth, developed economies still account for a large proportion of coffee consumption and consumer confidence in those markets can impact coffee prices. 


Comments:  Falling coffee prices are good for company margins as long as demand is not falling so fast as to impact sales to a significant degree.  Starbucks has its coffee needs locked into fiscal 2013.  Peet’s has its coffee costs locked though 2012 at increasingly favorable prices throughout.  Last year was a difficult year for Peet’s from a cost perspective. 





Supply: Egg sets placements continue to contract at around the same rate, -5%, according to the Broiler Hatchery report released by the USDA today. This implies that supply will remain tight as the industry looks for more favorable business conditions before expanding production.  As the chart below shows, supply is not showing any clear signs of picking up.



WEEKLY COMMODITY CHARTBOOK - egg sets wing prices





















WEEKLY COMMODITY CHARTBOOK - chicken whole breast











Howard Penney

Managing Director


Rory Green



Retail: What To Expect This Earnings Season

Conclusion: This should be one of the less eventful earnings seasons for the retail supply chain in quite some time. Expectations are in check, and management teams continue to have high hopes for a 2H margin ramp. They won’t back off of that pitch…until they have to later this year. The group is getting winded, with a 17x p/e on 23% consensus growth expectations, which is simply mind numbing. In this context, we like stories that have asymmetric factors that will allow them to work in any climate, such as LIZ, URBN, FINL, DECK, ANF, DKS NKE and RL. We don’t like names that will get stuck in the middle of the margin madness, such as KSS, JCP, HBI, GIL, CRI, M, TGT, SHLD and JNY.



Earnings Season for the Retail Supply Chain kicks off in earnest later this week with both Hanesbrands and UnderArmour showing their wares. We think that the broader take-away from this earnings season will be one of opacity and complacency – though it might not be fully apparent at the time. Companies have a great excuse in unfavorable winter weather, and little visibility into what the real underlying sales trends are in April due to the rather severe impact that the change in the holiday calendar is having on the top line. Specifically, Easter was on April 24thlast year, while this year it fell on the 8th. Given what we think is about a 3-week ramp of sales into the Easter holiday, the event definitely pulled sales forward into the month of March. As a result, companies who operate on a January – December fiscal calendar will recognize Easter spending in Q1 vs Q2 last year. We can argue anywhere from a 1% to 5% impact on sales results for March/April. The reality is that the companies are largely unaware of the actual magnitude of the shift either. But any kind of soft comps in April will probably be given a free pass by the market. In fact, we’d argue that it already has.


On top of the holiday calendar shift, the industry is at the tail end of a meaningful ramp in commodity costs that has the Street modeling a significant ramp in earnings growth in 2H12. That’s where we get concerned. People tend to forget that Gross Margins are not all about costs; there’s also a revenue/pricing component. Most retailers and suppliers are planning to keep lower commodity costs in 2H. But no few are banking on any peers breaking rank. JC Penney’s EDLP strategy will absolutely put Kohl’s on defense. That’s 12% of the apparel industry right there. What about Target, Sears, Amazon, Gap/Old Navy… The numbers start adding up. Margins are a zero sum game in this business. If prices come down, someone has to pay for it – either the brand, the manufacturer in Asia, the retailer, or the consumer. The only safe bet for us is that it probably won’t be the consumer.


To put some numbers behind the madness, consider the following…

a)      The current consensus earnings growth forecast for the next 12-months is 23%. We have not seen this kind of growth since we came off of recessionary earnings numbers in 2010.


b)      The market is giving this earnings growth a 17x p/e. We’ve only seen that kind of multiple five times in 3-years, but always at times when the group was still clearly under-earning. Who are we to say that it is NOT under-earning today? But to make this case, we need to see a considerable upshift in consumer spending alongside another decline in raw materials costs to push margins to new peaks. We don’t like that call.

Retail: What To Expect This Earnings Season - Consensus NTM Earnings Growth


c)       Revenue: 4Q was the first time in 3-years where revenue growth in retail was below 7%. Granted, it was on a tough comp vs the prior year, but the 2-year run rate has been stuck squarely at 10% for the past five quarters.

Retail: What To Expect This Earnings Season - 2


d)      EBIT Margins have been down for the past  three quarters by an average of about 50bps. The consensus is banking on a reversal in EBIT margins in 2H and in 2013. Such a sharp reversal would be the first time we’ve seen a non-recessionary rebound to that degree in well over five years.

Retail: What To Expect This Earnings Season - 3


e)      We’re going on six consecutive quarters where inventories are growing faster than sales. Maybe this supports the case for a sustained top line, but certainly not at the margin levels people are expecting in 2H.

Retail: What To Expect This Earnings Season - 4


f)       Without question, capex is on the rise. That’s not bad by any means, so long as the returns are ultimately there. But  the point is that the current run-rate of 3.4% of sales is likely to continue to creep closer to the 4% level – which crimps cash flow. Out of all these factors, this one concerns us least, as the space is largely sitting on too much cash anyway. That said, we think we’ll see an increasing bifurcation as to who can get a return on their investment and who can not.

Retail: What To Expect This Earnings Season - 5


g)      Here’s a notable callout. We all know that cost pressure is easing in 2H. But does everyone realize that we just saw container traffic pick up again after 10 months of being negative? Virtually 90% of the items we put on our bodies arrives into the US in a container. When costs are high, the industry pulled back order levels to keep margins in check. Now with costs planned to come down in 2H, we’re seeing retailers and suppliers get more aggressive with importing product. This plays into our concern about 2H Gross Margin risk.

Retail: What To Expect This Earnings Season - 6

the macro show

what smart investors watch to win

Hosted by Hedgeye CEO Keith McCullough at 9:00am ET, this special online broadcast offers smart investors and traders of all stripes the sharpest insights and clearest market analysis available on Wall Street.


Will management announce the elephant in the room on the earnings call next Tuesday?  They did not do so during a conference presentation three weeks ago. We believe they have to; at 20% of sales, the cost of bone-in chicken wings is too critical a factor for the company's EPS this year.  




Howard Penney

Managing Director


Rory Green



Ohio slippage shouldn’t stop the BYI train.



Even with the deferral of recognition of the Ohio units, BYI should still at least meet the consensus estimate for the quarter.  Our EPS and revenue projections of 67 cents and $232MM are in-line with consensus.  BYI will print their number after the close next Thursday. 


For those that have been getting our research for a while, you already know that we like BYI over the long and intermediate term.  Since we turned positive on BYI on October 6th (see our note, “BYI: WE’VE GOT THAT GOOD FEELING”), the stock has been on a nice ride up from $27.  Of course, with the stock up over 70%, they need to keep delivering for the stock to work from here.  While we’re not projecting a huge beat, a solid quarter and a favorable outlook shouldn’t disappoint investors who are in for the long term.



FQ3 Detail:


We’re projecting $81MM of gaming equipment revenue at a 44.5% gross margin.

  • 4,500 units
    • 1,000 international unit sales
    • 3,500 NA unit sales
      • 775 new unit sales, the majority of which were shipped to Revel.  Other shipments in the quarter should include:
        • Valley Forge, PA
        • Several Tribal expansion in Florida
        • Ohio casinos were shipped in the quarter but we do not believe that BYI will recognize revenues from these units until next quarter
      • 2,725 replacement units - The March quarter is usually a stronger replacement quarter than December.  We believe that replacement shipments in the March 2011 quarter for the market were just under 15k and estimate low single digit growth in replacements for the March 2012 quarter.  In the December Q, we estimate that BYI garnered 17% replacement share vs. 15% in the March 2011 quarter.  We expect their share to increase sequentially this Q.
  • ASP of $16.3k down QoQ but up YoY.  On the last earnings call the company cautioned that the high ASPs in the December quarter were driven by a high mix of Pro Curve games but that ASP’s going forward should be “more reminiscent of the prior two quarters.”
  • Margins on new game sales should increase sequentially as the December quarter was also negatively impacted by a high mix of Pro Curve units sold
  • $8MM of parts and other revenue

We’re projecting $58MM of systems revenue at a 70% margin

  • The opening of PH1 of Sands Cotai Central should provide a boost to revenues
  • Estimating 12% QoQ increase

We expect gaming operations revenue of $92.6MM at a 70% margin

  • March has always been a better quarter seasonally for BYI vs. the December quarter for gaming operations revenue
  • With the shipment of Greece units, we should see a tick up in WAP revenues
  • Another good quarter from NY lottery VLTs, benefiting from a full quarter of Resorts World NY at full capacity and continued growth in average win per day in NY, which were up 14% YoY this quarter

Other stuff:

  • SG&A: $61.5MM
  • R&D: $24MM
  • D&A: $6MM
  • Net interest expense: $2.5MM
  • Tax rate: 36.5%

HBI: Severe Pricing Gap Remains

We revisited the pricing disparity within HBI’s core basics category across 3 of its largest customers (WMT, KSS, JCP) which was prevalent in February. The pricing gap on like-for-like product remains what we’d call severe. 


In our 2/13 note "HBI: Pricing Disparity = Uncertainty" we addressed the gap in Hanes’ basics pricing across various mid tier department stores and mass retailers.  Additionally, we outlined our expectations for competition on price to heat up in 2H and as a result, while costs ease, pricing will buckle for HBI and offset the improvements on the cost side. In February, there was a prominent bifurcation in price points for like goods at KSS, WMT, AMZN & JCP. This gap is still in place today – down to the penny. Perhaps this is a positive for HBI that its customers are able to maintain such opacity. But we question how long the balloon can be held underwater.


Our expectations for price competition to headline the back half of 2012 stem from industry dynamics, primarily JC Penny’s radical shift in pricing which will stir defensive responses from KSS, SHLD (if it still exists), M, TGT and Amazon.  As of today, we have little transparency into what kind of traction JC Penney’s “Fair and Square” pricing strategy has gained on the consumer however we can say that from where we sit, Ron Johnson and team have started doing a better job conveying the strategy’s message. Previous ads have been replaced with the actual math (see below) – a watch that cost $30 last year, cost $21.99 when on sale (last year) and then $17.59 with an additional 20% off now costs $15…. everyday – clear as clear can be. Compare messaging from KSS vs. JCP. It’s like night and day.


Right now (and unchanged from February’s check), for the same commodity Hanes 5 pack of crew T-Shirts, KSS pricing is 36% above JCP. Likewise, for an identical 4 pack of boxer briefs, KSS pricing is 44% above JCP. After adjusting for online BOGO and volume incentives, KSS remains 42% and 50% above JCP for the same two items respectively. The pricing disparity here doesn’t address Wal-Mart who actually has the best price for Hanes’ basics in undershirts, boxer briefs & socks (see chart 2 below). Interestingly though, at WMT, across the 3 basics categories, Hanes’ pricing is at a premium to Fruit of the Loom & Starter (GIL) for the items we analyzed (chart 1).


Near term, we expect the results tomorrow after the close to be in line with consensus (-$0.33), if not slightly better. The company has been on the road constantly over the past two months and has been extremely bullish about its prospects. It has all the visibility it needs this quarter. But as for visibility into 2H, the lock on revenue evaporates.  Looking out to the intermediate term however and considering the implications a price battle could have for the commodity retailers like HBI, we’re shaking out at $1.54 vs $2.50E for F12. For additional takeaways following the 2/15 call, see our note "HBI: Fail"


HBI: Severe Pricing Gap Remains - WMT brand pricing


HBI: Severe Pricing Gap Remains - HBI basics


HBI: Severe Pricing Gap Remains - JCP ad


get free cartoon of the day!

Start receiving Hedgeye's Cartoon of the Day, an exclusive and humourous take on the market and the economy, delivered every morning to your inbox

By joining our email marketing list you agree to receive marketing emails from Hedgeye. You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in one of the emails.