“Laziness is built deep into our nature.”
Chapters 2 and 3 in Dan Kahneman’s “Thinking, Fast and Slow” are linked by laziness. I loved it – the author really forces you to ask yourself if you really know what you don’t know.
“Highly intelligent individuals need less effort to solve the same problems, as indicated by both pupil size and brain activity. A general “law of least effort” applies to cognitive as well as physical exertion. The law asserts that if there are several ways of achieving the same goal, people will eventually gravitate to the least demanding course of action.” (page 35)
Most people in our profession are, from an academic achievement perspective, considered “highly intelligent.” Odds are that if you are a Buy-Sider paying a Sell-Side desk a commission, the Sell-Sider might even call you “really smart.”
Really? How really smart is smart? Collectively, the Old Wall’s Consensus on Global Macro risk management issues hasn’t been smart for the last 3-5 years. It’s been lazy.
Let’s take, for instance, this newly wedded concept the Street has to “Risk On” versus “Risk Off.” The entire premise of that idea is just lazy. While it may provide a framework for people to talk about risk with the least demanding course of thought or action, it doesn’t change the fact that risk is always on.
Back to the Global Macro Grind…
Risk also works both ways. The #1 risk we have been beating on so far in 2012 is not Greece. It’s Global Growth. And the “risk” on Growth Expectations is to the upside.
Unless you’ve been living under a rock for the last 3 years, you’re aware the Greeks have more issues than Time Magazine. Last year alone, the Greek stock market crashed by another -51.9%. This morning, Greece is down -2.5% (and the manic media can’t find anything else to talk about but Romney’s taxes), but that doesn’t mean that the rest of the globally interconnected world ceases to exist.
Here’s how we think about the Natural Laziness of getting lulled into yesterday’s news: Market Prices Rule.
What I mean by that is that if you look at what the construct of real-time market price, volume, and volatility signals are telling you within a time horizon that’s Duration Agnostic, you can up the probability of not getting caught off-sides by consensus.
Across all 3 risk management durations in our model (TRADE/TREND/TAIL), here’s how Greece’s General Share Index looks:
- Immediate-term TRADE support = 669 (bullish breakout)
- Intermediate-term TREND support = 708 (bullish and holding that new support)
- Long-term TAIL resistance = 1109 (bearish)
Ok. Makes sense right? But maybe it only does because I just gave you a short-cut to think about risk within the context of the short, intermediate, and long terms. Is that good enough? Do you have an alternative process that’s better? How can we evolve it?
These are all questions that I encourage my team to push me on each and every day. Question the premise of the assumptions, particularly when our investment positioning is wrong. The market always knows something.
For now, only people who are short Greek stocks in 2012 can assure you of what the wrong position has been. Inclusive of today’s -2.5% selloff, Greece is still up +6.5% for 2012 YTD, beating the SP500 by 1.8% (1316). Who would have thunk?
In other globally interconnected news, Japan popped right back onto our risk management radar this morning with the following:
- Japan will not meet its top-line (GDP Growth) goals, again
- Japan will not meet its bottom-line (deficit) goals, again
- Japan is becoming increasingly annoyed with their failed Keynesian Experiment
How’s that money printing + fiscal “stimulus” model treating the old boy network in Tokyo?
Now if Japan didn’t have to roll over 31% of its debt in 2012, we might brush off what’s happening in one of the world’s Top 3 economies like Newt is trying to side-step his Freddie Mac compensation. But, we’re not dumb enough on the math to try that yet. We’re talking about rolling over 231 TRILLION Yens in debt ($3T USDs). Even by Fiat Fool standards, that’s a lot of Yens!
Relative to the US Dollar, the Japanese Yen, naturally, is down this morning on that “news.” As to why the Old Wall’s Consensus didn’t list a Japanese Sovereign Debt Crisis as part of their 2012 “biggest surprises”, we’ll just have to chalk that up to Natural Laziness too.
My immediate-term support and resistance ranges for Gold, Oil (Brent), EUR/USD, US Dollar Index, Nikkei225, and the SP500 are now $1, $109.31-111.26, $18.104.22.168, $79.63-80.44, 8, and 1, respectively.
Best of luck out there today,
Keith R. McCullough
Chief Executive Officer
Conclusion: The Japanese sovereign debt markets are beginning to look stressed, as noted by CDS that have widened (particularly versus the rest of Asia), as the re-financing needs of the Japanese government accelerate in 2012. As such, we believe the massive issuance on the horizon for Japan sovereign debt will continue to limit economic growth, over the TAIL, which is negative for Japanese equities.
Position: Short Japanese equities (EWJ)
Earlier today, Keith shorted Japanese equities in our Virtual Portfolio. Adding this risk exposure is a continuation of our long-term bearish research thesis on Japan (Japan’s Jugular), which we published a presentation on in 4Q10.
In addition to that work, we’ve published detailed analysis of the puts and takes of Japan’s banking system and its exposure to JGB risk – which is on the table in a major way in 2012, as the economy has to roll over 30.9% of its QUADRILLION-plus yen sovereign debt balance via redemptions and new issuance this year. To the later point, new issuance is expected to cover 49% of all expenditures – a record high.
Thoughtful analysis of the aforementioned puts and takes has kept out of the way of the short side of the JGB/JPY markets, unlike other notable Japan bears. That said, our propriety analysis suggests that the Japanese banking system may be on the hook for over $80B in capital raises should Japan be downgraded to an A+ equivalent by two of the ratings agencies (using Basel II standards). Currently, both Fitch and Standard & Poor’s ascribe a negative outlook to the country’s LT sovereign debt. This potential headwind may erode what is the main structural demand tailwind for the JGB market (surplus liquidity in the banking system).
Ironically, our models have Japanese real GDP growth accelerating through 2Q12E, as the country comps up against one of the worst natural disasters in modern history. We think being long Japan for that trade is the kind of investment that can sucker in those that fail to do enough of the background work. As such, we are taking the other side of this obvious (and consensus) tailwind and are electing to trade Japanese sovereign debt tail risk with a bearish bias for now.
As always, we are happy to follow up with further analysis. Email us if you’d like to start a dialogue on the subject.
Risk Managed Long Term Investing for Pros
Hedgeye CEO Keith McCullough handpicks the “best of the best” long and short ideas delivered to him by our team of over 30 research analysts across myriad sectors.
Conclusion: Chinese copper imports were up 78% y-o-y in December reaching a new high for monthly imports. We think this is an important and supportive data point of Chinese growth bottoming and supportive of our long Chinese thesis.
Positions: Long China via the etf CAF
Copper is often jokingly referred to as Dr. Copper with the insinuation being that copper has a Ph.D. in economics given its sensitivity to economic demand. Globally, copper use is broken down into the following categories of end market demand: electrical wires (60%), roofing and plumbing (20%), industrial machinery (15%), and other alloys (5%). As such, demand for copper is very economically sensitive and is often a leading indicator for economic growth, so the commodity’s nickname is fitting.
In the commodity markets, marginal increases or decreases in demand can be critical in determining price. One of our key Q1 2012 themes is Growth Slowing’s Bottom, which implies that economic growth is bottoming. The next phase, of course, is economic expansion, which will lead to increasing demand for commodities, such as copper. Interestingly, the most recent data from China on copper imports suggests that the Chinese may be beginning to prepare for accelerating growth, or at the least that the Chinese do not anticipate a slow down.
In the chart below, we’ve outlined copper imports in China going back to January 2008, which highlights that copper imports have been accelerating for seven straight months. Importantly, copper imports reached an all-time high for monthly imports in December 2011, up an astounding +78% y-o-y, to 406,937 metric tons. This acceleration in demand is particularly noteworthy in that Chinese imports were down in both 2010 and 2011, -8.4% and -3.0%, respectively. Thus, the December copper import data appears to be signaling that the demand profile for Chinese demand is improving.
The pickup in Chinese demand for refined copper comes at the same time as both GDP growth and industrial production have also provided support for our Growth Slowing’s Bottom theme and long Chinese equities position. Recall, China’s real GDP grew at +8.9% in Q4 2011 versus an expectation of +8.7% and industrial production grew +12.8% in December versus a forecast of +12.3%. Even though copper inventories in China are at a nine month high, the Chinese are clearly betting that demand for copper is poised to accelerate, so they are attempting to buy ahead of an increase in the price of copper.
In the global copper supply and demand model, Chinese growth and demand are the primary input. Depending on whose estimates we use or believe, Chinese is approaching anywhere between 40% and 50% of global copper production, the vast majority of which is imported from abroad. So, as Chinese growth shifts on the margin, it’s obviously very influential to the price of copper.
In the chart below, we’ve highlighted our current quantitative levels on copper, which highlight that copper has gone bullish TREND driven by the dynamics outlined above. It is important to note, though, that copper remains below its TAIL line of resistance at $3.98 per pound. To get incrementally bullish on copper, we will need to see it breakout above its TAIL line.
From a relative price perspective, we also took a look at the gold / copper ratio going back more than twenty years. Based on this ratio, and as the chart below shows, copper is near its cheapest level as priced in gold. Currently, one ounce of gold can buy 440 pounds of copper. This is more than one standard deviation above the twenty year average of 349, and it is 148% above the low for that period.
It is also noteworthy to highlight that the world’s largest importer of gold is India, who is expected to import 54% less gold in Q4 2011 than in Q4 2010. This is obviously in stark contrast to the growing demand from the largest importer for copper, China. At least partially, this is a function of copper prices being down -20.1% last year and much cheaper and gold being up +10.1% and being more expensive. If there is one repeatable pattern in investing, it is reversion to the mean.
Daryl G. Jones
Director of Research
Conclusion: The Brazilian economy remains in the sweet spot for equity investments and we continue to hold a bullish bias towards Brazilian equities for the intermediate term. Elsewhere, the fundamentals continue to suggest that King Dollar will appreciate versus LatAm currencies over the intermediate term TREND.
No Virtual Portfolio positions in Latin America currently.
All % moves week-over-week unless otherwise specified. As of Friday’s closing prices.
- EQUITIES Median: +2.8%; High: Brazil +5.4%; Low: Chile +1.7%; Callout: Brazil closed last week up +9.8% for the YTD vs. a regional median of +6.9%
- FX (vs. USD) Median: +1.2%; High: Mexican peso +3.2%; Low: Argentine peso -0.3%; Callout: Peru’s Nuevo sol is the only LatAm currency that has appreciated vs. the USD over the last six months (+1.7%)
- S/T SOVEREIGN DEBT (2YR) High: Colombia -3bps; Low: Brazil -16bps; Callout: Colombian 2yr yields up +116bps in the LTM vs. down -235bps for Brazil
- L/T SOVEREIGN DEBT (10YR) High: Colombia +1bps; Low: Mexico -25bps; Callout: Mexican 10yr yields down -46bps over the last month vs. up +24bps for Brazil
- SOVEREIGN YIELD SPREADS (10s-2s) High: Brazil +10bps; Low: Mexico -15bps; Callout: Brazil up +37bps over the past three months vs. down -48bps for Mexico
- 5YR CDS Median: -2%; High: Peru -0.9%; Low: Argentina -9.7%; Callout: Peru up +9.8% over the last three months vs. a regional median of -3.2%
- 1YR O/S INTEREST RATE SWAPS Median: -0.9%; High: Chile +0.7%; Low: Brazil -1.9%; Callout: Brazil down -6.3% over the last three months vs. a regional median of +2.5%
- O/N INTERBANK RATES Median: -0.3%; High: Chile +1.2%; Low: Brazil -4.6%; Callout: Brazil down -15.1% over the last six month vs. a regional median of -2.2%
- CORRELATION RISK Brazil’s Bovespa Index is becoming increasingly correlated with the S&P 500: +97% over the last three weeks vs. +72% over the last three months.
Full price and performance tables can be found at the conclusion of this note.
CHARTS OF THE WEEK
Brazil’s central bank lowered the country’s benchmark interest rate -50bps for the fourth consecutive meeting. The rate, now at a 18-month low, is now much closer to market expectations for Brazilian monetary policy:
Based on our propriety G.I.D.P. analysis, the Brazilian economy remains in the sweet spot for equity investments:
Moreover, the outlook for Brazil’s growth, inflation, policy, and equity market beta that we published at the top of our 9/1/11 note titled: “Eye On Brazilian Policy: Oh No You Didn’t” continues to play out in spades: “We view the central bank’s aggressive and proactive rate cut as supportive of Brazilian equities because it will likely coincide with a peaking of CPI and a deceleration in Brazil’s current economic slowdown. Our quant models aren’t in full confirmation of this, however, which suggests the turn is likely further out in duration.” Aside from TIME, the only difference between then and now is that the Bovespa’s quantitative setup is in full support of our bullish bias on Brazilian equities:
Growth Slowing’s Bottom:
- Mexico: Unemployment Rate ticked down in DEC to 4.5% vs. 5%; ANTAD Same-Store Sales growth slowed in DEC to +3.8% YoY vs. +14.6%.
- Peru: Unemployment Rate held flat in DEC at 7%.
- Brazil: For the fourth time since AUG, Tombini & Co. lowered the country’s Benchmark Interest Rate by -50bps, taking the Selic to 10.5%, which is the lowest since 3Q10. The latter point suggests to us that the QE2-inspired rate hike cycle has been completely reversed in Brazil, which is bullish, on the margin, for perception of Brazil’s intermediate-term growth prospects. Looking forward, Brazil should remain in quadrant #4 of our GIDA chart (see above) through Q1, suggesting further easing is likely. We received confirmation of this over the weekend, as O Globo reported that Rousseff is prepared to make fiscal adjustments to help the central bank cut the [Selic] by at least a another percentage point in 2012.
- Brazil: In addition to the currency headwind that is monetary easing, Brazil’s government is reported to be studying ways to stem the recent rally in the real. The inflection in USD-denominated loan rates (+14bps since Wed) suggests that the central bank may be hinting at additional dollar purchases.
- Mexico: Despite three consecutive months of acceleration in CPI to a mere 20bps shy of their upside inflation target, the central bank kept the country’s Benchmark Interest Rate at a record-low of 4.5% for the 24th-consecutive meeting. In fact, the monetary policy board led by Governor Agustin Carstens tilted their commentary to the dovish side, signaling that: a) their policy is consistent with their outlook for inflation; and b) that they stand ready to lower rates should growth come in to the downside.
- Argentina: Argentina’s Benchmark ARS Deposit Rate continues to make new intermediate-term lows, touching 15.6% today (down from a peak of 22.9% in mid-NOV). The trend is proof that President Fernandez was successful (over the short term) in her bid to slow capital outflows by increasing the supply of pesos in the economy by imposing USD scarcity via a series of repressive regulations. This does not include the latest scheme, which will force importers to require gov’t approval for all overseas purchases after FEB 1. The change is likely to limit imports on the margin in order to support the trade balance; that may ultimately serve to push up Argentine CPI as certain products become more scarce and/or more expensive to produce.
- Argentina: The peso’s -6.5% YTD slide vs. the Brazilian real has been supportive of Argentina’s USD-denominated sovereign debt, with yields falling -61bps to 10.7% (through JAN 18). This is because increased competiveness w/ Brazil, Argentina’s largest trade partner, is supportive for growth in the country’s FX reserves, which Argentina uses to service its USD debt burden.
- Argentina: The latest news surrounding Argentina’s sovereign default/bankruptcy proceedings takes us to D.C., where the Supreme Court asked the Obama administration for advice on whether it should hear an appeal from the hedge funds EM Ltd. and NML Capital (both units of Elliot Management Corp.). Having turned down both of Argentina’s restructuring attempts (2005 and 2010), the creditors claim they are owed at least $2B in principal and interest payments. The Supreme Court is specifically debating whether or not to rule on the funds’ failed attempt at seizing $100M in Argentine assets being held in custody of the Federal Reserve. A ruling in favor of the funds may set precedent for increased legal recourse for investors in the event of sovereign defaults – a very apropos subject given the current issues in Europe.
MOSHE’S BRAZIL NUGGETS
Moshe Silver, our Chief Compliance Officer, is fluent in Portuguese and mines the local Brazilian press for hard-to-get data points for us each day. Below, we flag his top three callouts from the previous week:
- Brazil’s national labeling program is urging consumers to trade in their low-efficiency appliances and lighting fixtures for those labeled “A”, which represents the highest level of quality and energy efficiency. A concerted marketing effort plus any new rebate program are likely to be a tailwind for Brazilian retail sales over the intermediate term.
- According to Valor, the $3.5B of foreign investor inflows into the Bovespa in the YTD (through first 12 trading days of 2012) is the highest in at least seven years.
- Brazilian leadership continues to demand more say in how IMF funds are allocated in exchange for its continued financial support.
THE WEEK AHEAD
Key economic data releases and policy announcements:
- TUES: Brazil: mid-month CPI (IPCA-15); Mexico: Global Economic Indicator; Argentina: Industrial Production, Consumer Confidence, and Shop Center Sales
- WED: Brazil: FGV Consumer Confidence; Argentina: Supermarket Sales
- THURS: Brazil: Central Bank Monetary Policy Meeting Minutes and Unemployment Rate; Mexico: Retail Sales and Presidential Election Poll (Consulta Mitofsky)
- FRI: Brazil: Aggregate Credit; Chile: Central Bank Monetary Policy Meeting Minutes
- MON: Brazil: FGV CPI (IGP-M); Chile: Industrial Production and Retail Sales
McDonald’s will release sales tomorrow before market open.
McDonald’s remains one of our favorite stocks in the restaurant space as the company continues to outmatch the competition in the United States (where the company derives almost 45% of its operating income) as it executes on its remodel program.
Within the earnings, we will be focusing on management’s forward looking statements around 2012 guidance; in particular, commodity basket inflation and any update on capex related to the reimaging program for the next 12-24 months. While additional pricing may need to be added to help the company absorb inflation, we expect December comps to impress once again and the top-line remains the primary focus for investors.
Below we go through our take on what numbers will be received by investors as good, bad, and neutral MCD comps numbers by region. For comparison purposes, we have adjusted for historical calendar and trading day impacts (but not weather).
Compared to December 2010, December 2011 had one less Wednesday and one additional Saturday. We expect a slight positive calendar shift as a result.
U.S.: facing an easy compare of +2.6%, including a calendar shift of between +0.4% and 0.7%, varying by area of the world and a negative impact of -2% related to weather:
GOOD: A print of 8% or higher would be received as a good result. Despite implying sequentially lower same-store sales on a two-year average basis, an 8% print would be a positive headline number and would beat consensus of 6.5% by a significant margin. We believe that the company continues to capture share in the domestic business and macro trends in the U.S. from December point to a continuation of the positive momentum in MCD U.S. sales. Our estimate is +8%.
NEUTRAL: A print of 7-8% would be received as a neutral result given that, on a calendar-adjusted basis, it would imply a significant sequential decline in two-year average trends while still coming in slightly above consensus. With the stock having traded up 15% during 4Q11, investors are pricing in a strong top line and we believe that consensus is conservative for December U.S. comps.
BAD: A result of less than 7% would disappoint investors as it would imply the lowest calendar-adjusted two-year average trends since May. And the steepest sequential decline in calendar-adjusted two-year average trends since December 2010 (which was largely caused by weather).
Europe: facing an easy compare of -0.50%, including a calendar shift of between +0.4% and 0.7%, varying by area of the world and a negative impact of -2% related to weather:
GOOD: A print of 11% or higher would be received as a good result for MCD Europe. We are setting the bar a little higher than the Street, which is at +8.4%. Our estimate for December is +11%.
NEUTRAL: A result of between 9% and 11% would be received as a neutral result for Europe as it would imply a print just above consensus but also a sequential decline in calendar-adjusted two-year average trends.
BAD: A print of less than 9% would imply a steep decline in calendar-adjusted two-year average trends.
APMEA: facing a difficult compare of +8.90%, including a calendar shift of between +0.4% and 0.7%, varying by area of the world:
GOOD: A result above +4.5% would be received as a good number as it would imply a sequential acceleration in calendar-adjusted two-year average trends. Our estimate is 4%.
NEUTRAL: A print of between 3.5% and 4.5% would be received as a neutral result as it would imply calendar-adjusted two-year average trends.
BAD: A print of less than 3.5% would imply a deceleration in calendar-adjusted two-year average trends.
get free cartoon of the day!
Start receiving Hedgeye's Cartoon of the Day, an exclusive and humourous take on the market and the economy, delivered every morning to your inbox
By joining our email marketing list you agree to receive marketing emails from Hedgeye. You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in one of the emails.