“We are scattering the substance that belongs to future generations.”
“In 1908, after the assassination of President McKinley, Fisher was appointed by his successor, Theodore Roosevelt, the youngest President of the United States, to the National Conservation Commission.” (Sylvia Nasar, “Grand Pursuit”, page 164).
Commissions and committees have been around forever. In times of crisis, successful leadership by government committee has rarely worked. Ultimately, a super-sizing of that committee concept isn’t going to work this time around either.
By 1909, Congress refused further funding of the National Conservation Commission. Today, they’d probably try to double or triple down on the idea as long as there were some bridges, roads, and teaching jobs to spinoff from it as “economic growth.”
The problem, of course, is that no matter what the American Keynesians try to do, the world’s economic growth continues to slow. As cyclical Growth Slowing in Asia and European Stagflation becomes more clear, Global Equity markets are becoming more red.
On the heels of last week’s nasty -16.2% year-over-year export slowdown in Singapore, the Monetary Authority of Singapore said: “The world economy and financial system are at their most fragile state since the 2008-2009 global financial crisis.”
Much to Timmy Geithner’s centrally planned chagrin, Singapore is China’s trusted economic advisor. When they say something like this – they mean it – and a man-made US committee isn’t going to be able to slow its implications.
Back to the Global Macro Grind…
This morning’s Top 3 Headlines on my screens are: 1. Super-committee Fails, 2. Spain Elects Center-Right Government and 3. Packers Move to 10-0. So at least there’s one team out there who is still focused on winning instead of whining.
Asian and European stocks continue to crash and the so called “Santa Claus Rally” in US Equities has never looked so rouge. Last week we were offered plenty of warning signs – here were some of the more important Macro callouts:
- US Dollar Index - had another solid week, closing up +1.45%, taking its cumulative gain since May to +6.8%
- US Stocks – SP500, Nasdaq, and Russell2000 down -3.3%, -4.0%, and -3.4% on the week, respectively
- US Equity Volatility (VIX) – up another +6.7% (up +113% since May)
- Commodities (CRB Index) – down another -2.5% (down -14.5% since May)
- Oil – WTIC down -1.6% vs Brent down -5.6% (breaking its TAIL line of $110/barrel support)
- Gold – down -3.5% on the week closing barely above TREND line support of $1722/oz
- Copper – down -1.7% and remains in a Bearish Formation (bearish TRADE, TREND, and TAIL)
- US Treasuries – long-term bonds continued to rally, with 30-year yields falling another -4.5% on the week to 2.99%
- US Yield Spread – continued to compress (another 10bps week-over-week) as growth continued to slow
- TED Spread (3month LIBOR minus 3month Treasuries) – up another 3bps on the week to +49 basis points wide
Those were some of the more obvious leading indicators that a US centric stock market investor may have incorporated into his/her risk management view.
Some of the less obvious week-over-week Global Macro moves were as follows:
- Argentina’s stock market down -8.1% (major funding issues continue)
- France’s CAC40 Index was down another -4.8% (we’re short EWQ)
- Austria’s stock market lost another -7.0% (moving YTD down to -38.1%!)
- India led decliners in Asian Equities, moving back into crash mode at > -20% from YTD peak (down -4.8% wk)
- Hang Seng down another -3.4% and continues to crash from YTD peak (we’re short EWH)
- Natural Gas down -7.7% on the week making YTD lows
- Palladium down -9% week-over-week
- Cocoa down -7.3% week-over-week
Obvious or not to consensus, all of these risk factors are measurable and incorporated into our globally interconnected macro view. It’s a lot of work. And it can be as boring as the day is long – but someone has to be your Risk Manager. Risk never sleeps.
Bottom line from here: Get the US Dollar right, and you’ll get mostly everything else right.
That’s been our call since May, and we’re sticking to it.
Yale economist, Irving Fisher, certainly made his fair share of mistakes – but one of them wasn’t ignoring how mathematical realities could drive inflations and deflations of prices.
He called it the “Money Illusion” – and what he ultimately missed was how much debt could perpetuate price volatility. Hopefully, Future Generations of economists figure out that debt’s impact on economies and market prices are not illusions. They are real-time.
My immediate-term support and resistance ranges for Gold, Brent Oil, CAC40, and the SP500 are now $1, $106.11-110.29, 2911-3135, and 1199-1240, respectively.
Best of luck out there today,
Keith R. McCullough
Chief Executive Officer
The Knapp Track report for October shows a sequential deterioration in casual dining trends from September.
Our estimates for Knapp Track October comparable sales and traffic were +0.5% and -0.5%, respectively. Actual comps and traffic came in at +0.8% and -0.7%, respectively.
Estimated Knapp Track casual dining comparable restaurant sales grew +0.8% in October versus a final accounting period number of 1.9% (versus the prior estimate of 2.0%) in September and +1.2% in October 2010. The sequential change from September to October, in terms of the two-year average trend, was -60 basis points.
Estimated comparable guest counts were -0.8% versus a September number of -0.2% (versus a prior estimate of 0.0%) and -1.2% in October 2010. The sequential change from September to October, in terms of the two-year average trend, was -20 basis points.
We are maintaining a favorable view of EAT on the TRADE, TREND, and TAIL durations and see the company’s positive traffic trends, at a time when the industry is seeing declining traffic, to be a positive sign.
Get The Macro Show and the Early Look now for only $29.95/month – a savings of 57% – with the Hedgeye Student Discount! In addition to those daily macro insights, you'll receive exclusive content tailor-made to augment what you learn in the classroom. Must be a current college or university student to qualify.
Conclusion: China’s banking regulator, China’s sovereign wealth fund, and the central banks of Singapore and Indonesia offered their updated outlooks regarding global growth, assorted domestic banking issues, and Europe’s Sovereign Debt Dichotomy. Hint: They are not constructive.
This week as another bad week for Asian equities, closing down -1.8% wk/wk on a median basis. India, a country still reeling with ill-effects of stagflation, led decliners (-4.8%). Indonesia (-0.6%) and Philippines (-0.2%) – two countries we’ve been positive on from a fundamental perspective over the last few months – outperformed on a relative basis, which is consistent with their performance over the YTD.
Asian currencies also had a weak week, closing down -0.7% wk/wk vs. the USD. New Zealand’s Kiwi Dollar led decliners (-3.5%) on a dovish 3Q PPI report. The Indian rupee dropped another -2.2% wk/wk (down -12.8% YTD) as the RBI announced a fresh round of quantitative easing measures designed to ease financial conditions. This is, on the margin, negative for the inflation outlook in India.
Asian fixed income markets were generally mixed on the short end of the curve; conversely, slowing growth continued to drag the long end of Asian sovereign debt yield curves lower. In Australia specifically, expectations of rate cutting continue to drag 2yr yields lower (-29bps wk/wk), while slowing growth domestically and in key trading partners helped drag down long end yields by another -14bps wk/wk. Turning to the interest rate swaps market we saw muted action across the region – which isn’t a surprise given the resilience of global energy markets. We call out Australia’s -8bps wk/wk decline in its 1yr O/S swap market as a continuation of the dominant trend (down -135bps YTD; -65bps below the RBA’s policy rate).
Asian 5yr CDS continued its general trend upward, widening +4.9% wk/wk on a median percentage basis. Not to pick on Australia (we are short the FXA in the Virtual Portfolio), but their swaps widened the most in the region by nearly a double on a percentage basis (+16.2%; +12bps) to 87bps. While hardly signaling any risk of a medium-term credit event, this is a noteworthy delta, on the margin, for a generally well-received sovereign (debt/GDP = 28.8%; deficit/GDP = -5.9%).
THE LEAST YOU NEED TO KNOW
- Zoomlion Heavy Industry Science & Technology Co., which is China’s second-largest maker of construction equipment, talked down guidance in an interview this week, saying the country’s demand for cranes and excavators will continue to slow next year. “Meeting the company’s 50 billion yuan ($7.9 billion) sales target this year will be challenging,” per CEO Zhan Chunxin.
- Hong Kong, which continues to struggle economically as a result of an assortment of domestic and international headwinds, saw its unemployment rate back up +10bps to 3.3% in October. Healthy still, but negative from a directional standpoint.
- Indonesia’s central bank lowered its 4Q11 and full-year 2012 GDP forecasts to +6.6% (vs. +6.7% prior) and +6.5% (vs. +6.7% prior), respectively, saying, “The impact of the global crisis will be more significant in 2012.”
- Singapore had a nasty week of economic data and the resulting commentary out of the Monetary Authority of Singapore speaks volumes to the potential for these trends (which are leading indicators for the global economy) to continue. Retail sales growth slowed in September to +3.1% YoY vs. +7.8% prior. More importantly, non-oil domestic export growth slowed in October to -16.2% YoY vs. -4.6% prior. Electronics exports (think AAPL) tanked -31.2% YoY vs. -13.6% prior. This is not what U.S./E.U. growth bulls want to see heading into the holiday season. If Singapore, which is home to the world’s most busy container port, isn’t shipping it, we aren’t buying it. It’s that simple. The MAS followed this sour data up by concluding the week with this very sobering comment: “The world economy and financial system are at their most fragile state since the 2008-09 global financial crisis.” Note: this view is incredibly counter to consensus calls for a year-end “Santa Claus” beta-chase.
Deflating the Inflation:
- China continues to send subtle signals that it’s in the early stages of easing monetary policy. First, the Ministry of Finance received 6% for 6mo deposits, down from a record 6.83% at the prior auction and the first decline in yields at a gov’t deposit auction since May. Moreover, the PBOC sold its 1yr bills at a lower yield for the 2nd straight week, (-9bps) to 3.475% - which takes the yield on these securities below the benchmark deposit rate for the first time since January. Not a ton of action, but easing on the margin, nevertheless. China’s reluctance to ease materially in the near-term is in-line with our view and with the views of Chinese officials: “The foundation of price stability is not yet solid… Extremely loose global monetary conditions and rising domestic labor and resource costs may exacerbate inflationary expectations… Current liquidity is in line with the nation’s growth.” (PBOC 3Q Monetary Policy Report)
- India saw its benchmark inflation reading come in at +9.7% YoY in October, which was unchanged from September. Our models point to one more month of sequential acceleration on a YoY basis and then a series of lower-highs in 1H12. This is roughly in-line with the RBI’s latest outlook, which expects CPI to trend down to +7% YoY by March ’12 – a stipulation for them remaining on hold. Unfortunately, they decided to compromise their hawkish lean by deciding to coordinate with the central government and purchase an additional $2 billion of federal debt via POMO at the end of November. Deputy Governor Subi Gokarn said the move was made to “ease a [temporary] cash shortage” in the financial system. We, on the other hand, are inclined to think they are doing this to aid the central government issue additional debt. The last five auctions failed to attract enough bids at desirable yields and 31% of the bids at the latest bond auction were rejected. We have growing suspicion that the Finance Ministry will upwardly revise their FY11 borrowing program for the second time this year – a view supported by their decision to increase the cap on foreign holding of rupee bonds by +20% (hoping higher yields will spur demand from international investors). Moreover, the Finance Ministry has issued $17 billion worth of unscheduled “cash-management” bill sales YTD (up +7x YoY) and on an accelerating basis of late (+$2.2 billon last week).
- Indian corporations’ international funding markets have gone completely dry this quarter, with issuance dropping to levels not seen since 2Q09 as average dollar-borrowing costs rose to a 2yr high of +626bps over U.S. Treasuries. Heightened capital markets volatility makes it tougher for EMs to price dollar debt deals, meaning less new USD supply globally and less conversion of USDs into other currencies as a result.
- Pardon our lack of groundless optimism, but we continue to see signs that the EFSF will struggle to attract capital – especially on the order of our estimate of $2-3 trillion needed for the upcoming fiscal year. Gao Xiqing, President of China Investment Corp (the country’s sovereign wealth fund) had this to say regarding the potential of them reallocating assets to aid in the Euozone bailout: “When we talk about international investments, we must consider whether they serve our interests… We can’t say that we’re a generous nation and we can help you at whatever economic costs to us.” Additionally, Jin Liqun, Chairman of CIC’s board, had this to say as well: “China cannot be expected to buy the highly risky bonds of euro-zone members without a clear picture of debt workout programs.” No translation(s) needed.
- Japanese real GDP growth accelerated in 3Q to flat on a YoY basis (from -1.1% prior). On a QoQ basis, the country finally broke out of recession (started in 4Q10) with a +1.5% growth rate (vs. -0.3% prior).
- In a bid to help China’s local governments smooth their cash flows and asset/liability management, China’s Finance Ministry recently introduced a pilot program to allow its select local governments to issue debt directly to the market (vs. through LGFVs). Shanghai priced the first issuance of fixed-rate securities in this program, yielding 3.1% on the 3yr tenor and 3.3% on the 5yr tenor – yields at/below China’s sovereign debt. By comparison, 5yr yields on AA-rated corporate debt (most LGFVs are AA or below per Chinabond) yield 6.73% on average, suggesting to us that there’s an extremely wide disparity in credit quality for China’s sizeable local gov’t debt burden ($1.7 trillion and growing).
- China Banking Regulatory Commission, the country’s financial services regulator, explicitly warned lenders that some projects backed by local governments would run out of funding as property sales continue to decelerate. Moreover, it told banks to prepare for a rise in NPLs and step up asset sales and debt restructurings for “high-risk” property developers – if not cut them off from additional financing entirely. It also pointed out that the recent trend for property developers to procure credit from non-traditional sources at much higher interest rates heightens the probability they default on their official bank loans… Net-net, we think their stern warning sends a message that China is unlikely to relax property market curbs anytime soon. “Prepare for some short-to-intermediate-term pain, the CBRC is essentially saying to the nation’s bankers.
Keith bought EAT in the Hedgeye Virtual Portfolio this afternoon as the setup in his quantitative model was favorable. From our angle, too, the stock looks good on the long side.
From a fundamental perspective, as we wrote in our note titled “EAT – CAN THEY EXECUTE?” on 10/27, we believe that the company is operating well and will continue to improve going forward. At Chili’s, the remodeling program, kitchen retrofits and other initiatives are going to boost sales and customer satisfaction. As our note following earnings (10/27) highlighted, we believe that the skepticism among the sell-side community is misguided and would not interpret this negative sentiment as being anything other than a positive for a buyer of the stock. Having met with the company earlier this week (note titled “EAT MEETING”, dated 11/15), we are further convinced that Brinker is out-innovating the competition and, as a result, will outperform over the longer term TAIL duration.
This stock has been one of our favorite names for some time and is one of our top three long picks in the space over the intermediate term and long term despite it being overbought on the TRADE duration.
daily macro intelligence
Relied upon by big institutional and individual investors across the world, this granular morning newsletter distills the latest and most vital market developments and insures that you are always in the know.