The Economic Data calendar for the week of the 15th of August through the 19th is full of critical releases and events. Attached below is a snapshot of some (though far from all) of the headline numbers that we will be focused on.
THE HEDGEYE BREAKFAST MENU
Notable news items and price action pertaining to the restaurant space.
University of Michigan Consumer Confidence was a BOMB this morning, coming in at 54.9 versus 62 expectations and 63.7 prior.
According to the Bloomberg consumer confidence index, sentiment dropped 1.5 points, to -49.1 for the week ended August 7; dropping back near its mid-May low and only 5 points from its all-time low.
Retail sales rose 0.5% in July, the largest gain in four months; excluding autos core sales grew 0.3%, down from the upwardly revised 0.5 June figure. In July, growth was led by miscellaneous retailers, gasoline stations and electronics and appliance retailers. On the down side were Sporting goods and hobby stores, department stores, and building supply stores.
Thank in large part to GMCR, the QSR category has performed strongly relative to its peers. What we would call out here is the improving performance in Food Processing, a space that has been heavily beaten down throughout the recent phase of high levels of inflation in agricultural commodities.
JCP reported adjusted earnings of $0.13 coming in well below its own guidance as expected, but it ‘managed’ to come in above both our $0.07 and the Street’s $0.10 estimate on lower quality earnings (i.e. further SG&A cuts). In addition, the company is guiding Q3 lower, but instead taking full-year guidance down as we expected they simply pulled it altogether. So much for transparency. JCP continues to be at the top of our short list. Here are a few other callouts:
Conference call at 9:30am
The total percentage of successful long and short trading signals since the inception of Real-Time Alerts in August of 2008.
Last night RRGB reported 2Q GAAP diluted earnings per share of $0.44 versus $0.36 consensus. On a non-GAAP adjusted EPS were $0.48, compared to adjusted EPS of $0.29 last year. Importantly, Red Robin's company-owned comparable restaurant sales increased 3.1% driven by 4.5% increase in average check, which was partially offset by a 1.4% decrease in guest counts.
That was the good news.
On the conference call, management said “through August 7th, the first four weeks of 3Q11, same-store sales were up 0.5%; driven by a 5.8% increase in average check and 5.3% decrease in guest counts. This compares to same-store sales being up 1.4% in the first four weeks of 3Q2010, which were driven by a 2.7% decrease in average check, more than offset by a 4.1% increase in guest counts.”
In my view, the biggest problem was that management used the macro environment as an excuse. The roller coaster in US equities which has been down ~13% over 14 days of trading (over the last three weeks the VIX is up 44.1%, 26.7 and 36.3% (through Thursday), respectfully) as the reason for the decline in traffic. The stock market is a discounting mechanism and is clearly, over the last two weeks, implying deep concerns about the future prospects of the U.S. economy. For RRGB, though, the consumer has been impaired for some time and management’s clinging to the macro environment for an excuse is not convincing.
Declining traffic trends are always a concern and, while management is attributing this slowdown to the macroeconomic environment, we would contend that there is likely more to it than that. It is unlikely that such a sequential deceleration in traffic can be entirely accounted for by soft macroeconomic trends. The consumer environment has been challenging for some time. The Bloomberg Weekly Confidence Index is only 5 points from its all time low. On the other hand, gas prices have come down, albeit to still-elevated levels. While the market plunge has definitely shook confidence, we do not believe it has caused the Red Robin consumer to stop bringing his/her children for a burger.
The RRGB turnaround is progressing and management is forging ahead with acceleration in new unit development. The decline in traffic trends overshadowed what was otherwise a strong quarter and this is a worry for investors going forward.
I guess we were right to worry about FY12 guidance but this is well below what we expected. Don’t expect our estimate to go there though.
Meet and lower is what we expected, but not this much lower. Below is management’s guidance for FY2012:
“At least” $2.15 for FY2012? Thanks for those two words of comfort. While sympathetic to current BYI shareholders, we really like the setup for would be investors. This is a complete sandbag – nothing less. We scrubbed and scrubbed and we can only get down to $2.40. Our guess is that the real guidance should’ve been “at least $2.40”. And to throw salt in the wound – or icing on the cake for new investors – JPM slapped a downgrade on the stock this morning cause it’s now a show-me stock. This stock could trade with a 2 handle this morning implying a 12x forward 12 month P/E on what we see as a bad case estimate. Ridiculous but opportune.
Look, we are pretty certain the gaming supply business will exhibit very strong long-term growth. What’s really attractive about BYI though, is they have a near term growth driver beginning in the back half of FY12 the other guys don’t have. I’m talking systems and it is visible. So even if replacement demand takes another year or two to materialize – mathematically it has to at some point – BYI begins its growth cycle much sooner. Please see our 8/3/11 note “BYI 4Q POSTVIEW” where we laid out the back ended loaded FY2012 and the systems visibility.
The quarter was actually decent and we didn’t see much in there that was disconcerting – one reason why we don’t buy into the $2.15 number. Here are some observations from the quarter: