COLM: Post Q Follow Up

As usual, a noisy quarter from COLM, but what was unusual is that the company beat – big (i.e. 20%). While my team nailed the trends in underlying business (and KM nailed the stock), I definitely ‘missed the beat’ in translating it to the model. I expected a ‘guide down that won’t matter’, which I think we got. But my math tells me that the consensus is likely to come out too low.

The biggest negative is that the Spring backlog is down 11% and management’s tone was very guarded. But as outlined in my earlier post, we’re seeing retail sales pick up in dollars, units, and average price. Maybe reorders are not coming in at a robust rate, but it is not because the market is flooded with product and is being heavily discounted. We’re seeing quite the opposite. Not bad given that Columbia is gaining share in 4Q.

Even with the stock presumably trading up meaningfully tomorrow, I think we have better margin visibility with COLM than others in the group. The SG&A evolution is key here, as the company is finally at a spending level that will help ignite some top line growth.

It’s been a long time since I said this, but I kinda like this story. I think that COLM maintains its trajectory in the quadrant chart below for at least a couple quarters. See my two earlier posts for more color on my thinking on this name.


St. Louis is probably one of the most dynamic gaming markets in riverboat land. PNK’s Lumiere Place opened last year and another PNK property will open in South St. Louis County next year. A statewide referendum on the ballot in November could eliminate the loss limit in exchange for a 1% higher gaming tax rate.
  • We’ve done some revealing work on local housing prices as the most important driver of gaming revenues over the past 15 years (see “IT’S THE HOUSING STUPID, 7/17/08). We all know what is happening with housing nationally but it is instructive to view the variable on a localized level. As shown below, St. Louis homes did not experience the explosive pricing growth as other parts of the country. Gaming revenue growth was also more moderate. For this reason, I expect declines to be on the reasonable side as well which makes St. Louis one of the more attractive gaming markets. This is all relative of course.
  • The other attractive feature of the market is of course, the potential for the loss limit elimination. PNK and ASCA are the clear winners should the referendum pass. Polls indicate that a slight majority favor passage. Missouri remains the only state with loss limits in place, effectively repelling significant high end business. ASCA could experience a 10-15% net increase in EBITDA over time from the loss limit removal.
  • PNK appears on track to open in South County late next year which will negatively impact same store revenue. Ameristar and Argosy (PENN) look to be pretty insulated from the new competition. Harrah’s Maryland Heights will feel some impact but the major market share losers will be PNK’s own Lumiere Place and President, and the privately owned Casino Queen.
  • Given the horrendous results following smoking bans in Illinois, Atlantic City, and Colorado, everyone seems to be focused on this issue. We are fairly optimistic we won’t see a smoking ban any time soon in Missouri. A smoking ban proposal was last rejected in 2006.
  • ASCA generated 27% of its EBITDA in St. Louis and should be the prime “beneficiary” of less bad results in this market and the potential loss limit removal.
It's the housing, stupid!
On a relative basis, STL exposure is probably a good thing


Smith Travel released their forecasts for the hotel industry today. For 2009, they are projecting a RevPAR decline of 2.5% but an ADR INCREASE of 1%. It looks like the fudge variable in that regression model of theirs may have been fudged a bit too much. It’s not simply a matter of hotel companies getting better at holding rate. At some level of demand, the yield and profit models will dictate lower ADRs. We believe that level will be reached next year. HOT’s guidance of down 5% RevPAR may even turn out to be aggressive.

Hedgeye Statistics

The total percentage of successful long and short trading signals since the inception of Real-Time Alerts in August of 2008.

  • LONG SIGNALS 80.43%
  • SHORT SIGNALS 78.34%


We have been keeping our eye on bullish supply data points for South American Arabica recently. The demand side of the coffee equation is less clear, clouded by the impact of the economic slump on consumers as well as Asian capacity for Cheaper Robusta.

Global Coffee Prices spun into a nose dive in the late 80’s after the collapse of the International Coffee Agreement. As major US household brands like Sara Lee and Kraft shifted rapidly to lower quality Robusta and other cheaper grades, South East Asian growers began to ramp up production dramatically. Nowhere was this more pronounced than in Vietnam, which is among the largest global suppliers after less than a decade of rapidly increasing export levels.

Prices for Vietnamese exporters have fallen dramatically over the past month, with the Vietnam Coffee and Cocoa association reporting average levels of $1,700 USD per metric ton vs. $2,500 in February. Anecdotal reports suggest that there has been a pronounced decrease in buyers from Western Europe and the US combined with a sudden collapse of credit facilities for local brokers and traders. Meanwhile news reports from Indonesia, the second largest Asian producer, suggest that there has been a drop in demand felt there as well (a recent uptick in exports of Robusta is largely due to settlement of forward contracts dating back to early in the season).

The presence of low cost providers like Vietnam and Indonesia complicates the global coffee picture. Although they are primarily producing the less desired Robusta variety they have tremendous capacity and miniscule labor costs.

Andrew Barber


The VIX swung sharply higher today as options buyers rushed into the market at any cost. If you read our work you know that we look for spiking VIX levels as a signal of capitulation selling, but today’s spike feels more like a fund(s) being forced to cover short volatility positions as it does a true indication of sentiment.

Andrew Barber


Keith’s Trade line levels today are a buy at 858.33 and a sell at 945.36.

Andrew Barber

real-time alerts

real edge in real-time

This indispensable trading tool is based on a risk management signaling process Hedgeye CEO Keith McCullough developed during his years as a hedge fund manager and continues to refine. Nearly every trading day, you’ll receive Keith’s latest signals - buy, sell, short or cover.